The hype is real.
portnoy_dont_know_shit11/6/22, 9:17 p.m.
Great pie. Not worth a 3 hour wait, as some people have endured. But, when you get there just as they open, it’s a great pie. Perfect amount of char. Sweet sauce. Classic New Haven pie. Is it much different than Pepe’s? Not at all. Pepe’s is still my all time favorite though. And for that, Sally’s scores slightly lower.
crtsdsnkrs11/6/22, 1:35 p.m.
Great pizza, incredible atmosphere. This is the gold standard for what you should look for in a dine-in pizza spot.
will.ketelsen11/6/22, 2:18 a.m.
This is easily some of the best pizza around. My friend and I took an hour and a half drive here and then waited an hour in line and it was definitely worth it. The crust is crispy, the sauce and cheese were great, and it wasn't oily at all. I definitely highly recommend.
john.mucciola11/5/22, 11:55 p.m.
Unbelievably good. Great sauce just the right amount of cheese and a ridiculous crust. Might genuinely be the best pizza I’ve ever had would absolutely recommend and definitely worth the wait
sean.newsome111/5/22, 4:21 p.m.
Excellent pizza. Sauce has a bit of tang, crust is nice and crispy.
mcbythesea11/2/22, 11:48 p.m.
Delicious! Had it before and thought it could use a bit more cheese. This is with extra cheese and it did not disappoint. Cooked perfectly, great ingredients. Highly reccomend!
curtis.willcox10/30/22, 9:58 p.m.
Long awaited visit and first time trying Sally’s. Initially, my hopes were too high and was surprised when it tasted like a regular pizza. The sauce was delicious and tasted like fresh tomatoes. The crust was perfectly cooked and left a satisfying char on my fingers. The cheese was crisp and not greasey in the slightest. All in all, a great pie. Tasted like an 8.9/10 but our sever gave us an extra pie that was never picked up- So Sally’s gets a 9.1/10.
r.mccoy10/29/22, 1:04 a.m.
The char on this pizza and the flavor in the crust is AMAZING! The sauce tastes like rich, fresh tomatoes. Cheese didn’t really have much flavor. We ate this back to back with Frank Pepe’s. They were very close together. Sally’s barely outdid Pepe’s for us.
michael.weckenbrock10/27/22, 5:14 a.m.
On the way back from Boston had to stop. This is by far one of the best pizzas ever. I wouldn’t recommend the large get a smaller one. I got a small white which was fantastic. The garlic the cheese crust all of it was all around the best white pie I ever had. The regular was also fantastic thin and crispy. Competitor down the street got nothing on this
s.rind10/25/22, 10:10 p.m.
Being from Jersey I have eaten a lifetime of quality pizza. Sally’s is the World Series grand slam in the bottom of the 9th of pizzas. Crisp crunch and flavor abounds. This is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. Sally’s > Pepe’s, Bar, and modern.
evan.goodwin10/18/22, 2:06 p.m.
Look at that pie. Makes you want to cry. Great pizza. Crust was very good (though it was burnt a bit on the edges so some of the actual crust bites were a tad inedible— a common side effect from the coal fired oven). Great sauce with a nice amount of tang, and just the right amount of cheese. The pizza was so light, me and the GF crushed the whole thing in like fifteen minutes in the park right down the street from the restaurant and still had the energy to move afterwards. Not all pizzas can make that claim. Must try.
michael.ursery10/17/22, 9:52 a.m.
I can’t emphasize how much this pizza has changed over the last year. Less cheese, less toppings, and less service. What happened to this New Haven tradition?
bkpizza16010/16/22, 4:43 p.m.
Ok, so I can say without a doubt I had the best pizza in my life yesterday at Sally’s. Everything about this pie , cheese to sauce ratio, crisp, char!! I went all over New Haven and they were all good but Sally’s stood out for me.
rafay.seyal10/16/22, 2:30 a.m.
Sally’s!! The sauce was spectacular! We had the tomato pie - classic! We also got the mozz - heaven! Perfect char, delicious cheese and the crust is so good. It’s pretty much mana from heaven. Enjoy!
ysltorres95410/16/22, 12:12 a.m.
DIFFERENT….. One of the best for sure. The sauce and mozzarella are top tier. The undercarriage is beautiful and 0 flop.
david.ancelet10/10/22, 2:23 p.m.
This has the best sauce I have ever had. Totally worth the trip.