I was so excited too try this pizza I got there there was a line had to wait about 40 minutes in the cold But it was so worth it!! Just don’t make the Mistake I did I ordered 3 large pizzas and one medium and the two large I got meatball pepperoni onions and bacon and sausage. Well when I got my bill of 149.70 I just about had a heart attack. 575 per topping. I don’t thank that’s right. But oh well. This is the best pizza I had.
dylan.scuderi2/23/21, 10:10 p.m.
Very very good pizza. Heavy flop and little to no grease. As good as it gets when it comes to pizza. Follow my pizza review IG: scoobapizza
28 views•2 likes
b.mac22/19/21, 11:25 p.m.
What can I say, it’s the pizza capital of the world! Easily better then modern, the za has a nice undercarriage, cheese is high quality, sauce is fresh and the crust is crispy. A well deserved 8.9 the only reason it’s not a 9 is the crust was a little overcooked and there was a little too much sauce.
kyledaluz2/17/21, 10:17 p.m.
Good, crisp pizza. Light cheese and great sauce. Not much wrong with it. Probably depends on the pie.
pizzavore2/16/21, 11:05 p.m.
Large cheese apizza, 4pm on a Tuesday Pros: Thin, crispy, off the charts delicious. Great sauce, the texture of the undercarriage and crust is wonderfully thin and crispy. Char flavor underneath and in the crust is spectacular. Cons: Nothing Verdict: I'm not sure if this is the best pizza I ever had. It's either no. 1 or tied for no. 1 with Johnny's in MT Vernon, NY. I had Pepe's down the street just before this (8.9) and even with no appetite I ate this pizza no problem because its a mythical legendary pie. I like Pepe's but Sally could put Frank in a headlock or some kind of full-nelson maneuver, no contest
daniel.sullivan32/12/21, 11:20 p.m.
Eating this cold and its still better than 98% of other pizza
mike.aim2/12/21, 1:15 a.m.
Excellent pizza. Something about it was "dry"?? It's really good though
foodiggity2/12/21, 12:46 a.m.
Amongst the Apizzas of New Haven, Sally’s is truly unique. By far the thinnest of the bunch, this is bar pie at its best. Very fresh, strong tomato flavor may not be for everyone, but this is the type of pizza you just can’t get anywhere else.