funsizemike.5/24/23, 8:16 p.m.
The crust is slightly burnt and the best part of the pie. Sauce is excellent. Only downfall is needs more cheese, the lack of cheese keeps it in the 8’s. Still have to put Johns of Bleeker and Ralph’s in Nutley Nj above them. Pro tip let it rest for 5 minutes before consuming.
brandon.hardman15/22/23, 3:23 p.m.
Words can’t describe how delicious this one tasted. Definitely one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. So worth the wait. Do yourself a favor and make the drive!
big.show49695/20/23, 12:29 p.m.
First time trying Sally’s and they did not disappoint. Pic was after 35 minute drive home. Best crust I have had. Crisp with excellent char but still chewy. Very unique. Very good ingredients. Sauce was amazing. So glad I finally got to try. Definitely worth the hype!
peter.mitchell5/19/23, 8:30 p.m.
Great cook on the crust. Love that char. Good sauce and very good cheese. Bonus - great music
christian.bowe5/19/23, 8:27 p.m.
Very good pizza. I love the cheese but thought basil and garlic could make the pizza better. The crust was really charred as well. Sauce was good but on the sweeter side. Overall, it’s very over hyped and I don’t believe this to be a 9 plus pie. Very good but not great.
jack.schenone5/16/23, 2:26 a.m.
BEST PIZZA EVER! Drove 2 hours for this and it was totally worth it. Our waiter, Matt, was awesome. Guy was hilarious and definitely made my experience 10x better. The sauce was out of this world good. The cheese and crust ratio was perfect. Everything tastes fresh. The crust was just the right amount of char and crunch. The small slices did throw me off but was so good anyway. We also had a pepperoni and the pepperoni was also amazing. Overall this was the best I have ever had and would definitely drive 2 hours again to have.
ethan.hatch5/14/23, 6:47 p.m.
The Mozzarella and tomato sauce pizza is the best pizza here. Didn’t get a picture of it before we finished it. Excellent tomato sauce. Nice crisp to the pizza.
daren.nezol5/1/23, 1:45 a.m.
Absolutely Delicious, no grease, fantastic sauce flavor. Bit of flop, great undercarriage and perfect crust. Only thing that could have been better was add just a tiny bit more cheese to the pie
noah.dana4/24/23, 5:01 p.m.
Sally’s was good but waiting 2 hours rly killed it for me I understand it’s a high rated spot and it’s amazing but I was expecting more I’ll stick to my fav spots local. Will be back to try Pepe’s.
abuzubriko4/23/23, 7:52 p.m.
Absolutely unbeatable. Must try for anyone visiting or living in new england. The best cheese pie youll ever try.
artie.mase4/23/23, 5:38 p.m.
Really enjoyed this. Actually liked the taste better after it cooled a bit.