bdubs..3/22/23, 10:07 p.m.
Sally’s pizza wow. We get to Sally’s pizza at 2:20 when we get there we walk inside and asked to order to go they then tell us to go outside and order at the counter which is in the middle of the sidewalk but no big deal we wait until someone comes out after a couple minutes and asked to order half pepperoni half plain pizza to go. They tell us that their next pick up time is at 3 o’clock. What is a pick up time never heard of it who knows but if it’s good pizza it’s probably worth it so we decide to wait. Also, the pizza was $26 for a medium which is pretty crazy but if it’s good it’s worth it so we decided to wait and pay we go to the car and sit until 3 o’clock comes around which we go and get the pizza and asked for a Gingerale. They tell us they only have it in 1 L which we decide to decline because only one person wants it but before then they try to describe to us what a leader is and how many people we can give like we are idiots or something. He decides to simply get a small Coke bottle instead which is a ridiculous $4.25. Then we get to the pizza which at this point seems I’ve been sitting for at least 15 minutes because it is barely warm. We take it back to the car and eat it as soon as we got it. Basically we open the box and the pizza is lukewarm but it does look OK so we eat it, the plane side was below expectations in the very mid the pepperoni on the other hand honestly was very good but was it worth 40 minutes and $31 no it is not. Dave should revisit it and see what it’s like now I think he would change his rating to a six after all the service you would have to deal with. Also, it looks like a blind man cut the pizza if you can see in the picture Some slices are the size of Chuck E. Cheese slice some of them are big chunks, and some of them are a little slivers. I think the man behind the counter cutting it might have no arms wish I could’ve read it higher, but honestly mid.
crashtestfool3/7/23, 8:34 p.m.
Great sauce and cheese little more char on the crust than my liking.
mc3_photo3/6/23, 11:54 p.m.
Perfect crust, great cheese, sauce is a bit bitter, but great pie overall
ianj3/3/23, 1:51 p.m.
Pitstop on our way from Philly to Boston. Worth the 15 minute excursion. Everything I dreamed it was.
craig.elwood3/2/23, 6:33 p.m.
Full Disclosure, I had a pie here a month ago n I didn’t rate it. It would have been a 9.3. Today’s pie was really a 8.9. So I’m going to score the average……. Certainly one of the best pizzas I’ve EVER eaten. Can’t miss here!
joe.jazz3/1/23, 4:47 p.m.
Got here around 12noon. Beat the rush. Pizza was great. The last couple times it has been cooked to perfection. I have had it where it was realy burnt and subpar. crispy and tasty.
weston.rilling2/19/23, 3:05 a.m.
Yummy and Cheesy and the crust is good and also the sauce has such a good taste . It’s has nice employees and good deserts
ryan.colella2/18/23, 10:57 p.m.
Hands down, best pizza I’ve ever had. Similar sweet sauce. This is a must try. Thin, great char. Zero sag on the lift!
tom.kaminski2/16/23, 10:53 p.m.
Actually very good classic New Haven style apizza. Get extra cheese on it. Otherwise something is amiss.
tonymootz2/12/23, 4:36 a.m.
Grew up eating here, as did my father and my grandfather before him. Sally’s is a sacred place. Perfection. The last time I was there I had what was possibly the best pie I’ve ever eaten. The density of the crust was so on, thin but substantial, crispy but not crackery, and the sauce….. Beautiful. The Consiglios are pizza sorcerers of the highest order.