Not crispy enough. Too doughy. Great coal fire taste tho
calimondi7/30/20, 8:44 p.m.
🔥 🔥 🔥 pizza. Sauce was flavorful. Perfect amount of cheese, the dough could have been cooked a little bit more but overall great pizza
rschafer7/30/20, 8:06 p.m.
One of the biggest disappointments of my life. Why this pizza sucked: -Barely any cheese. I was excited to order the classic mozzarella, but I hardly got any mozzarella on this pie. -Barely any sauce. Most of the sauce was baked into the bread. I couldn’t taste any pure sauce on my tongue. -The sauce had a weird tang and tasted like it came from a cheap store brand can. -The bread was hardly crispy. I was expecting a big crunch with every bite, didn’t happen. It’s now been 24 hours and I am still disappointed!
onemorehundred7/27/20, 6:21 p.m.
Never had a pizza that El Presidente scored higher than a 9 till today! He is right on! I live in Brooklyn NY and in south Brooklyn this place would be busy 24/7 if it was there! Absolutely amazing!
jwest99187/26/20, 3:56 p.m.
Definitly lives up to the hype. Very good pizza. Nice and crispy with a delicious sauce. Alittle flip but I think that’s due to the long slices.
patrick.widdoss7/25/20, 10:53 p.m.
Wtf was Dave on when he rated this? I mean it’s good but I’ll start the conspiracy theory that I think he was paid by the town of New Haven to boost scores. I made a vacation out of this and haven’t had one place that was better than jersey pizza. Even average jersey pizza.
haley.ferreira7/25/20, 11:54 a.m.
Great pizza. Good amount of cheese, sauce, and grease. The bottom of the pizza tastes too charred for me though and I did a light bake
mike.gips7/24/20, 7:42 p.m.
Highly anticipated. Very good, but crust was surprisingly not very crisp. Modern had a better crust.
blair0lewis7/21/20, 5:35 p.m.
Cheese is something special. Sauce is good, but it’s a secondary taste to the cheese. If you flirt with borderline burnt (I’ll call it toasty) crust, this is your kinda mouth concert.
laurr7/21/20, 5:32 p.m.
Oh Sally’s!! You stole my heart with that burnt crust and charred coal flavor. The sauce and cheese combo is irresistible. One slice is never enough!!!
martin.menze7/20/20, 12:57 a.m.
Great pizza. Definitely beats Frank Pepe. Drove from Long Island, NY for it.