I went here directly after having Frank Pepe's, so I can directly compare the two better than most. Sally's arrives to your table a comically large box, and it surprisingly fills the entire thing! The pizza itself is extremely thin with quite a bit of flop and very little crunch. The flavor of the sauce is very unique and enjoyable, but there is nowhere near enough cheese on this pie! Maybe I had too high of expectations after watching Dave's review and seeing the 8.8 rating on the app, but I have to say that Sally's actually let me down quite a bit. Maybe I got a dud, but I have this near the bottom of the New Haven options.
ryan.risedorph1/15/22, 5:04 p.m.
Drove all the way from NE Indiana to the pizza capital of the world!
william.manto1/14/22, 12:58 a.m.
Lotta taste, Lotta flop, Smokey yet balanced, nice cheese to sauce ratio. Crunchy crustickles.
5 views•0 likes
pizzadaily1/13/22, 11:20 p.m.
This pie is a 9.6. This is perhaps the best pizza I have ever had. Perfect balance and absolutely amazing flavors!
sean.hughes21/9/22, 2:16 a.m.
I’m a 9.4 on Sally’s. Phenomenal pizza. Needs a little less flop. Phenomenal taste, sauce, cheese ratio
23 views•1 like
seth.mclaughlin1/8/22, 5:27 p.m.
Not what I expected but a pleasant surprise. Well done pizza with a blacked crust. Very sweet sauce which I liked and balanced throughout the pie. Best one I’ve had so far
sebastian.pumillo1/5/22, 9:15 p.m.
After getting some more sauce in a bite, raised score after video.
14 views•0 likes
christopher.keslow12/20/21, 6:26 p.m.
PICKED UP THE PIZZA RIGHT ON TIME. TOOK IT OUT TO THE CAR AND OPENED IT BECAUSE I COULD NOT WAIT FOR A SLICE! And this is how it looked, ice cold! I can not believe it! I have been waiting for ever to have this pizza. Save your self the time and only eat in! DO NOT ORDER THIS PIZZA AND TAKE HOME, and the pizza needed more sauce. Very un happy. Guess I won’t be going back!
bear.bru12/20/21, 2:18 a.m.
Preferred the slices at the top of the pic that were a little more cheesy. The perfect cheese, crust, sauce ratio. Slightly salty, crispy, coal fired.
mia.morton12/14/21, 10:22 p.m.
NY pizza got nothing on this. Hands down the best pizza I’ve ever had.
petemd12/7/21, 4:31 a.m.
Got a cheese pizza from Sally’s. It is just okay, some positives but nothing anywhere near as good as the pizza back in San Francisco.