Sally's Apizza

Delicious pizza! A New Haven must.

Very good pizza! Happy with the choice to come here!

Sally's in Fairfield. Honestly pretty damn close to the original.

Redoing a recent rating. Was originally a 9.0 but after further consideration, it was the ebst pizza I have had. Everything was perfect from the sauce to cheese, it was so crispy perhaps a bit too crispy

Could use a tad more cheese. The slip was flopping. But over all good pie!

Gas

My husband and my son think this is the best pizza in New England. I thought it was good, but not great. I just don’t like the overly charred pizza. I would score it a 7.9.

Super good! No flop, good undercarriage, burned my mouth on the first bite. Pepperoni was a bit small but it got my high score on our Pizza Tour 2024

Dave was right about the score for the most part . Great crust, great sauce, great cheese . The only things I could see wrong was the incredible wait to get in then the even longer wait to get the actual pizza . One other thing was the pizza didn’t have much char on it but I understand it’s not an exact pie every time. Nevertheless this is a spot any pizza fan needs to visit at least once!

New Haven’s finest Apizza! Only the wait disappoints. Crust, sauce, & char all on point!

Easily one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. The sauce was perfect and not too much cheese either. Paper thin just like I imagined as well

Sally’s was something special. The greasy, lava-like pie. Best sauce ever tried on a pizza.

Great pie, sauce could use a little zest.

Incredible crisp & amazing sauce. You don’t find pizza like this in most places

Hard to beat the New Haven Ct pies. Tomato pie it’s my go to.

It’s good, we drove from PA, Moonlight Pizza two miles from our house, Sabatini’s about an hour away. My wife and I think they’re both better. Like I said, it’s really good, but…

Amazing. Not as good as Cherry Hill King of Pizza in NJ