Good, great crust. Prefer more Cheese
chris.brumwell10/29/20, 7:07 p.m.
Most def one of the GOATS could’ve used a little less char on the crust but would eat this every day
chiway10/27/20, 2:52 p.m.
Lives up to the hype but my nyc bias remains strong. Does not go beyond 8's.
aileen.clare10/26/20, 2:57 a.m.
Like how thin it was and the overall char. However sauce left a lot of flavor to be desired. And crust was too burnt, tasted so ashy.
ecao10/25/20, 6:43 p.m.
Plain mozzarella: GREAT pizza; sauce is unmatched; a bit of a sweet and savory taste, but just right; not much cheese, but it is made very well and of very high quality; very crispy on the bottom and crust, but much cleaner and less sloppy than Peoe’s; great dough too; a bit floppy, could be a bit firmer
patrick.smeraldi10/23/20, 1:06 a.m.
Excellent and huge pie! Nice crisp on crust and very thin. Great tomato sauce! Bit too much char for my taste. Zero grease. Huge variation in slice sizes. Long awaited and worth the 45 mile journey from home! Said it would be ready at 5:00 pm, and it was ready just a minute prior. P.S. tell no one, but between you and me, I ate 1/3 of the pie, which was maybe 6 slices! Diet blown for sure, but don’t GAS :) (give a sXXt)
tony.springer10/21/20, 3:59 a.m.
Drove 2 hours for this pizza and it did not disappoint the next day had John’s on Bleeker which I thought was very mediocre all hail the pizza king !!!!!!!
funky.pizza.lover10/19/20, 10:38 p.m.
Great pep; very good sauce, but a little stingy (would recommend ordering extra); extremely large pie; crispy undercarriage yet sufficient chew on the inside; for those who like coal oven, the distinct smokey undertone is a nice compliment; meets the high bar set for this place; order well in advance!
c_zim10/17/20, 11:18 p.m.
Sauce and cheese phenomenal. No flop. Gotta get your order in ahead of time to beat the crowd. Favorite in New Haven.
pzrocks10/17/20, 6:22 p.m.
Freaking Spectacular! The sauce, the cheese, the undercarriage! This is a MUST!
andrew.krachie10/17/20, 6:06 p.m.
Very good, feel like char is overpowering. Tomato sauce less sweet than normal. Great color on top and bottom.
blake.wetzel10/15/20, 4:32 a.m.
In our 4th and final review of the day, Evan Santos gives this pie a 9.0, as we conclude our trip to the pizza capital of the United States, New Haven, Connecticut.
26 views•1 like