Long time coming to try this pie out! Had high expectations and it did not disappoint! Whole pizza was absolutely divine and really enjoyed the charcoal taste on the undercarriage and crust. Not the mention the mootz too🤌 Definitely will be coming back sometime again even though it is 8 hours away😅
robpizzaguy8/11/22, 12:49 a.m.
Phenomenal pizza, thin crust and cooked just right. Nice well-done char. Some of the best pizza I’ve had. A must try.
csech7028/10/22, 6:07 p.m.
the customer service was great - very light crisp pizza. Worth the wait!!
alexspizzajourneys8/7/22, 11:15 p.m.
Back in New Haven. The Best pizza I have ever had, tried both e tomato pie and the regular cheese. Got a tour of the brick oven. And very friendly service. 9.7 that’s a review. 🍕🍕
shawn.hibbs8/7/22, 6:54 p.m.
Great pizza, very well balanced. Usually crust is an afterthought to sauce and cheese but here it is equal.
michael.weinberg8/6/22, 3:09 a.m.
Perfect pie. Super well done and the crust is thin. The ingredients are quality.. the sauce is perfect and the dough great. More sauce then I prefer but I am enjoying my first stop in New Haven. - Bonus: The white with garlic and basil was fire. Pizza is worth the trip. Bring some home.
jim.basil8/4/22, 1:05 a.m.
First time here and wanted to compare to Modern which is my favorite. This was outstanding and my girls loved their clam pie! I rated this .1 lower than Modern based on a touch more flavor. But, this was so close……
jo-jo.walsh8/3/22, 7:00 p.m.
Definitely an excellent pie. Thin with nice crunchy crust. More saucey than chessy. Taste is perfect…
vitonardo8/2/22, 9:00 p.m.
Disappointed in Sally’s. Idk what Dave is thinking unless the new owners changed something. Still it’s an above average pie.
scpi678/2/22, 12:48 a.m.
This one lives up to the hype. Sally’s is my new gold standard. It’s what I hoped it would. Enough said.
nicksonebite7/31/22, 12:10 a.m.
Grew up in Connecticut and outside of Pepe’s best ever. There isn’t much to say that anyone else hasn’t.
jessica.pioggia7/28/22, 2:52 p.m.
This was so good, thin and crunchy and tasted so fresh I would get this again for sure
raider67/25/22, 6:40 p.m.
Great great sauce; love the bricked bottom. Nice and thin. Excellent