Sally’s is our second stop on our Trinity Tour. One Bite.
joe.carfagno9/12/21, 4:18 p.m.
Took way too long coming out so not surprised the crust was overly charred. Clearly left in oven too long. That being said the non-crust portion was phenomenal and would give it another shot at the 9s!
eric.graham69/11/21, 5:17 p.m.
Tomato pie and a “Mootz” at Sally’s. Really, really good pizza. Staff was very friendly and accommodating. They took us into the kitchen and let us take some photos of the old coal fired oven. Crust at Sally’s is thin and crispy, with just a little chewy mixed in. Delicious!
nitwitt9/10/21, 3:52 p.m.
Was expecting more. Great tomato flavor. Good crunch. Heavy char but pizza served warm not hot. Probably would try again when they are less busy. Still worth the trip.
lpot9/7/21, 10:28 p.m.
Excellent pizza. We ordered the sauce pie and and plain with hot peppers and both had me licking my fingers. I definitely recommend going and it’s not burnt it’s crispy
e.goldsmith9/4/21, 10:00 p.m.
Delicious thin crust pie. Great crisp and unique flavor to the crust. One of the better pizzas I’ve had. Not my type of sausage for a pizza so would order without next time but scored based on crust/cheese/sauce/texture..not toppings.
pizzaolarfgs9/4/21, 12:38 a.m.
Finally made it to Sally’s. I have been to Pepe’s several times. It is a good pizza, but you have to be a sauce lover. Their ratio of sauce to cheese is a bit high. The crust was thin and charred just like a true Apizza should be.
pizzaqueen079/1/21, 3:40 a.m.
Had to come all the way back from New York to new haven just for this! Definitely up there with one of my favorite pizza spots. Everything from the sweet sauce to the thin crust and the char. Very worth the long travel here! Added some basil on top which definitely made it even better. Delicious!
jason.cave18/30/21, 12:27 a.m.
Nothing like Sally’s. Nice sauce, good bite, perfect char. Little bit too thin but still a fav.
ohmypizza8/29/21, 4:12 p.m.
I’m mildly disappointed. Came in here expecting to have the best pizza I have ever had. Avg 8.8 and the Prez gave it a 9.2 but it quickly fell from grace. The cheese somehow disguised its flavor. The tangy sauce shined in this one on most slices. I enjoyed the crisp and the tangy tomatoes but other than that it was adequate.