Reviewed both Pepe and Sally’s same night. Sally’s is a full point better. Crust is much better with better flavor and crunch. Sally’s has good amount of sauce and higher quality. Great pizza! Get this one!
adammjensen2/28/21, 9:33 p.m.
Tried and true NYC pizza eater- best pizza I ever ate. Everything on point 👌🏼
jesse.eberle2/28/21, 8:15 p.m.
Excellent pizza. I like going with half cheese and half marinara and garlic
deanoh512/26/21, 5:49 p.m.
Legitimate one bite?? Lol. Honestly this pizza was incredible. The boys threw a Rook 9.0 at it but it was amazing. We’re sad driving away right now.
23 views•2 likes
dylan.scuderi2/23/21, 10:10 p.m.
Very very good pizza. Heavy flop and little to no grease. As good as it gets when it comes to pizza. Follow my pizza review IG: scoobapizza
65 views•3 likes
b.mac22/19/21, 11:25 p.m.
What can I say, it’s the pizza capital of the world! Easily better then modern, the za has a nice undercarriage, cheese is high quality, sauce is fresh and the crust is crispy. A well deserved 8.9 the only reason it’s not a 9 is the crust was a little overcooked and there was a little too much sauce.
kyledaluz2/17/21, 10:17 p.m.
Good, crisp pizza. Light cheese and great sauce. Not much wrong with it. Probably depends on the pie.
pizzavore2/16/21, 11:05 p.m.
Large cheese apizza, 4pm on a Tuesday Pros: Thin, crispy, off the charts delicious. Great sauce, the texture of the undercarriage and crust is wonderfully thin and crispy. Char flavor underneath and in the crust is spectacular. Cons: Nothing Verdict: I'm not sure if this is the best pizza I ever had. It's either no. 1 or tied for no. 1 with Johnny's in MT Vernon, NY. I had Pepe's down the street just before this (8.9) and even with no appetite I ate this pizza no problem because its a mythical legendary pie. I like Pepe's but Sally could put Frank in a headlock or some kind of full-nelson maneuver, no contest