Sally’s is the best clam white pie in New Haven, and anyone who disagrees has a gutter pallet that can’t be trusted to distinguish a fudgsicle from literal dog shit. Out-of-towners may balk when they first see the charred crust, but that is just the ignorance urging you from venting into the mist of the unknown and exploring what is essentially the pizza equivalent of burnt ends. Sally’s is tradition, and a brick oven that has been operating for a near-century cannot be replicated. Fellow pizza connoisseurs, I assure you that no matter what mood you’re in, a Sally’s pie will immediately improve it: - Happy - Stoned - Sobbing uncontrollably for days after a breakup - Shoving a dead hooker into your trunk - Kicking a sick cat - Bullying the elderly - Warding off the dark voices in your head - Mid-afternoon panic attacks in the office bathroom - Stealing your neighbor’s disability checks - Drunk And for God’s sake, its “ah-beetz.” Get that normie “pizza” nonsense outta my face. RUNNER UP PIE: Sausage, peppers, and onions
jmpizza2227/2/22, 12:32 p.m.
So good. The crust had no flop and all crunch. You can taste the history of the oven in this pie.
mike.harding6/30/22, 9:20 p.m.
Perfect pie. No flop. Thin. Crispy. Great undercarriage. Sauce is to die for. Best pie I’ve ever eaten.
simonstoops6/29/22, 11:33 p.m.
Yummy! Burns the roof of your mouth off! Got the first pie of the day and it was worth the wait and met all of my expectations
jaykbirdd6/29/22, 7:37 p.m.
I never understood why people liked the New Haven Style. Frank's we got one at Mohegan, burnt. Hate it. 40 bucks to Doordash a burnt Sally's. I get it, it's "char" well I call it burnt. I don't get it. I don't want to.
iamdanhale6/29/22, 12:02 p.m.
Absolutely tremendous pizza. Incredible taste, crunch, texture... this is a must try!
sam.baker56/27/22, 10:44 p.m.
Fantastic.. Literally the best pizza I've ever eaten, good customer service too
nikitagubenko6/26/22, 1:22 a.m.
Long time coming to try this pie out! Had high expectations and it did not disappoint! Whole pizza was absolutely divine and really enjoyed the charcoal taste on the undercarriage and crust. Not the mention the mootz too🤌 Definitely will be coming back sometime again even though it is 8 hours away😅
m.love6/23/22, 10:30 p.m.
Excellent Pie. All ingredients were tasty and none heavy. Slight char on the crust. Just enough cheese sauce and dough. Didn’t pick up the slight tang in the sauce until my 3rd bite. Definitely warrants the high scores.
motelman6/23/22, 2:05 a.m.
If you can handle the hour and half wait for takeout or eat in the. This place is for you. The pizza is old school flavor that super thin and crispy. You keep wanting more after your first slice. No joke. A must stop. Parking sucks so be prepared!!
pizzakingonebite6/17/22, 1:44 a.m.
Best pizza I have ever had. It’s amazing how much better this pizza is.
chris.keenan6/16/22, 6:46 p.m.
Don't need to say much about this place that you don't already know. Dominant.
m.b716/14/22, 10:49 p.m.
i personally am not a big fan of pizza, but this was pretty good. although the crust was a bit burnt, i would eat this again.
tom.garofalo6/14/22, 12:32 a.m.
Worth the trip! Really thin, great sauce crust and perfect under carriage.
nblack886/13/22, 10:50 p.m.
The whole reason you get into the pizza game. One of the all-tie greats. The sauce. The crisp. The char. No doubt it sits on Pizzas’s Mt. Rushmore
henrytrodden6/12/22, 3:25 a.m.
Cannoli pie… the best goddamn desert I’ve ever had. No joke. Get the damn cannoli pie.