*THIS REVIEW IS ON SERVICE NOT PIZZA QUALITY* Hard to do a One Bite review when I didn’t get one bite of pizza after over an hour wait. Nothing in my life has compelled me to write a review more than the disastrous experience I had at this establishment. I waited over an hour on a Monday night for ONE large mozzarella pie. At least 4 groups that sat down after us received their larger orders before us, not to mention countless order pickups that received their orders immediately upon arrival. Should have known it was going to be bad when a bottle of water wasn't brought to our table when ordered at the counter. Absolutely appalling service that showed 0 urgency to get us a pie despite multiple complaints, and didn't even know the table numbers were (as they brought pizzas to wrong tables on multiple occasions). Took them 45 minutes to even update us that a delay was existent, saying it would be out in 20 minutes, which was not the case. Servers kept saying they were "all backed up" on a Monday night, despite being half full when we arrived and prioritizing pickups over all outdoor patrons. Manager was only there to give refunds, did not check on any table despite the ridiculous delay. It is beyond me how one cheese pizza took at least over an hour. I say at least because my table never received our pizza and are currently hoping for a refund. Could not be more upset, would rather just get Frank Pepe's down the street and eat in my car. Will be going to Frank Pepe's every time I'm in New Haven in the future instead. After my experience today Sally's does not deserve a second chance.
garo9/19/20, 7:32 p.m.
Beautiful charred crust , nice mozz, red sauce good . The best of New Haven
jim.joynt9/12/20, 3:51 p.m.
Passing through New Haven, Ct on El Presidente’s advice has to stop and try out Sally’s Apizza. Well worth the stop. Coal fire, thin crust tomato pie with mozzarella and meatball. One of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had.
j.baci9/11/20, 3:22 a.m.
Excellent crust that’s hard to match. Cooked perfectly with great char and nice and thin. We ordered 3 large pies including 2 large cheese. First one we had was good but too light on the cheese so we missed out on having that flavor. As we ate the 2nd one it was actually better when it cooled down and had enough cheese this time to experience more of that flavor. I was debating with myself if it should cross into the 9’s but I decided against it because the only knock I could find against this is it is missing that delicious milky cheese flavor I really like. For example my review for Sauce pizzeria they had that excellent Milky cheese flavor mixed in with there great sauce and good crust so it crossed the 9 range for me. Otherwise Sally’s has the best crust I’ve had on a pizza. Only one that rivals it in my view is Johnnys of Mt Vernon which I still need to give a review. Overall a delicious pie and I highly recommend.
brian.gat9/6/20, 10:05 p.m.
Very good. A little salty. Maybe crust overbunt on piece or two but didn’t bother me. Top place
justinsilver9/6/20, 6:20 p.m.
Came here with the highest expectations. Rented a car from NYC and drove to New Haven. Got the original tomato pie and was pretty disappointed. Crust was pretty burned up beyond your normal char. Tomato sauce was a bit too thick. Bottom was pretty crispy and taste was over just solid. Not mind blowing. GF got the pepperoni on top and pulled the score up a bit. Pepperoni’s were decent, medium to thick cut, definitely oily, but not overly salty. TLDR: good if you’re in town, but not something to travel for.
ryanloewy9/6/20, 3:58 p.m.
The holy grail Frank. Light, zingy marinara, great undercarriage, perfect char. Just absolutely beautiful. That’s a fucking review Frank!!!
kailyn.smigelski9/3/20, 10:02 p.m.
Terrific crust/texture, but still prefer a solid football pizza
easty9/1/20, 8:06 p.m.
Quality old school slice. no rhyme or reason as to how this is cut up. sauce has an electric tang.
matthew.jennett9/1/20, 4:52 p.m.
Great overall pizza. Literally bread cheese and sauce, which is what pizza is, but you could taste each ingredient specifically and it was a treat for your tastebuds
bryan.falco8/30/20, 8:59 p.m.
Amazing bar pie. Thin crust. Crispy. Cheese is well done witch I like. Sauce in tangy. And a really good sauce to cheese ratio. Great pie
anthony.anderson18/27/20, 4:12 p.m.
Very good pizza! Definitely worth the stop over on the way up to Cape Cod.
9 views•2 likes