Sally's Apizza

Very good pizza but honestly was expecting it to be better with the hype. Sauce was good but different & seemed almost bland … char was perfect. Thought the slices were too thin & wasn’t a full bite … Honestly Frank Pepe’s is significantly better… just my opinion… it’s worth a try though.

Had some flop. Sauce was amazing. Char on the pie was amazing. Great pizza!

Came in with high expectations, unfortunately the pizza under delivered. Very little flavor, too hot/soupy, and very charred if that’s what you like. The wings were very good.

Overall, great Apizza. Char was excellent and so were the ingredients. It had a little too much flop but really there isn’t much to complain about. Service was great too.

Amazing

Phenomenal char, light, crispy, just the right amount of chew and awesome balance of flavors

Very good but not as good as the New Haven location.

It's a good New Haven pizza! Is it 1:1 to the original? No. There's history, heritage, and experience in those old New Haven ovens that make this new location of a New Haven Pizza institution just a little green yet. Still best pizza you can find around here if you believe that New Haven is the crown jewel of pizza styles.

Pizza was good today, much better cook and closer to Wooster St than last time. Cucumber Collins A+. Out of clams and the garlic shrimp not so good. Have a pizza & cocktail be happy!

Subject for a new review, opened within the past couple months. Ovens need to be broken in. Irene said 5.1. She is a New Yorker.

Amazing pie

Man does this pie disappoint. This is nothing like the Sally’s in New Haven and honestly severely hurts the reputation. The drop off from this to the original is more severe than Pepe’s. Really bad. 7.2, I should honestly give it a 5.2, but the ingredients are still good.