Sal's Gilbert Pizza

Ordered an extra large Supreme Thin crust. Tremendous flop. Ingredients slid off the pizza. Do not recommend this pizza. Looking forward to coming back and seeing other pizzas that they make

Solid 7. Everything is good but nothing special.

Forgot to take pics before we ate. This is great pizza!

Dave’s review is pretty on point. Really good football pie. Not gonna knock your socks off but it absolutely will not disappoint.

Good flavor, crisp is great! Sauce is very tasteful, and the crust is perfect definitely recommend!

Freakin delicious! Their cheese is phenomenal.

I came here after watching Dave’s review so I have zero bias. I gotta say this is GREAT pizza. Zero flop, tangy sauce and a perfect crisp. I would drive an hour to have it again. I disagree with the 7.5

Great flavory sauce and it tasted pretty fresh. Not cooked long enough though which left for a very doughy and chewy crust.

Solid pizza, this score is an average of 5 people. The crust was the best part, a little too saucy for me. The garlic knots were tasty.

Fresh Ingredients, Super light. Some flop but crispy crust. Very good quality.

Perfect burn and undercarriage! Nice crunch and a very light flop! Good pizza

Awesome NY style pizza. Best in the West since 1989. They must be doing something right!!

Spaghetti and Meatball Pizza

We are from jersey and have a hard time finding pizza we like this pizza checked all our boxes. Excellent

7.7 Grandma, 7.6 Cheese, 7.7 Pepperoni

Worth the 55 mile drive! Best pizza so far in the Phoenix AZ.area

Lasagna pizza and Chicken Pesto

Excellent crunch around the crust score would have been higher but a little floppy undercarriage

Best pizza in AZ, hands down!!

Sal’s review #2 - 2 specialty slices Grandmas slice - 8.1 - the sauce was amazing and the crust was crisp, highly recommend the grandmas slice. Chicken pesto - 7.1 - the chicken pesto was on par with the whole pie I ordered before and was decent, a ton of chicken & cheese.