Sal’s Neighborhood Pizzeria

Pretty good slice

Slightly too much cheese but excellent crust and sauce. Legit old school pizzeria.

Burnt and greasy. Took an hour and half. $30.

Good sauce good crust although floppy probably due to the all the cheese and it was slightly greasy solid pie for the island. Great atmosphere go have some wine and eat some pizza the staff is great and it’s fun!

There is nothing special about this pizza. Over cheesed and undercooked. Pretty floppy. Pizza in the south stinks for the most part and this is consistent with that.

Good pizza especially the sauce. Served very hot ! Old school Little Italy vibe.

Vibe is amazing. Plain cheese was great and topping were so fresh. Sauce flavor was🤌. Crust was so crispy but soft inside. Loved and will be returning!!

Solid score for a solid pizza. The dough is the difference. Great story about Sal makes this a must try if in the area.

This is great pizza. By far the best on St. Simons. Perfect undercarriage, great crust, fantastic flavor with a nice tang. Good amount of grease which I am a fan of as a pepperoni lover. Highly recommended!

The marshal pizza is amazing. This place is fantastic.

This is a tasty slice. I would rate it higher but this pizza has major flop! Cook the bottom a little more and it would be a winner.

Pretty basic looking pie. Little on the greasy side and little flop. Could use more sauce but overall pretty solid for a southern pizza.

Pepperoni and sausage. Could have a crisper crust and more sauce. Prob still the best pizza on the island so it’s always the go to.

Solid day drinking beach pizza. Crust could use some work. Little bit floppy. Good taste.

Fine overall flavor but nothing spectacular. Dough has zero crisp. Not bad for football pizza.

Little flop. Hands down best pizza on St. Simons. Crust is fire!!

A solid average slice. The crust was too doughy. Looks like a good NY slice but comes up shy.

Above average slice for the south, coming from a New Yorker