Cheese and sauce are good but the crust is so bland
jim.cardona4/29/22, 12:47 a.m.
Found an Old Forge pizza in Allentown, had to try it… great sweet sauce that reminds me of home but the crust was thin tough and blah (should be light and fluffy), and just regular mozzarella instead of the iconic cheese blends, doesn’t live up to the name but bonus points for trying Got a plain slice and they hooked me up with a second, didn’t give a fair shot since it was reheated but it’s a fine slice, 7.9 all around
tunacan9/29/21, 5:22 p.m.
Solid pizza, only had time for counter slices would like to try a while pie sometime. Sauce and cheese were basic but good, dough/ crust was the best part. Definitely worth a stop if you are in the area.
mbarron9/8/21, 10:27 a.m.
Great slice.. best with a fresh pie of course.. located in a nice area of Allentown.
chris.cringle6/8/21, 6:15 a.m.
Pretty depressing location. Plain slice was really greasy and had no crisp.
tharizz11/13/19, 6:11 p.m.
It was fresh out of the oven however the crust was kind of soggy but the cheese was melting and hot it was really weird. I would’ve gave it at least a full point more if the crust would have been more well done. Good flavor sauce and cheese though
jordan.jionni8/5/19, 1:17 a.m.
Wanted a plain slice but it looked old and not great. Sauce had decent flavor but chunks of vegetables in it. Overall just not pleasant to me.
dab.errlhardt7/12/19, 3:55 p.m.
This is a pretty good slice, just a little greasy because there’s a little too much cheese, and the crust is a little too thick/crisp for my liking, but the sauce pulls it all together and saves it from being any less than a 7. You can tell these guys care about the food they make, def their own original style of pie.