zack.walsh1/19/21, 8:20 p.m.
Very good cheese slice, the doughy and soupy consistency in the middle separates it from great, salad made with perfect crisp (unlike cheese slice) and average Sicilian. Not quite an 8.
chrisbrady1/8/21, 8:08 p.m.
Good but not great. Thought it could have cooked a little longer but overall a good pizza.
mitch.gurevich11/20/20, 1:01 a.m.
Old school spot famous for the Sicilian (not my favorite style). I think Renapoli in Greenwich does it better. Tons of cheese on this one, which I don’t hate
pizzavore10/4/20, 2:31 p.m.
Large cheese pizza, 5:55pm on a Saturday, $18.00 Pros: Sauce and cheese are good, nice bubbling around the crust Cons: Nothing that unique about it Verdict: Should be noted I didn't eat the pizza right away, it cooled off a lot by the time it was cracked into. Could it have scored higher if I ate it right away? Not by much, as I got a good sense of what it's about based on taste, ratios and cook level. I'd say it's a textbook pizza, right on par with what you'd expect from a Westchester pizzeria. There's a lot of hype around this pizza but it doesn't do anything special to set it apart. If I were in Florida, I'd be thrilled. In New York, it's standard - which is still very good. It's NY Pizza.
jack.homola9/4/20, 5:13 p.m.
Greasy slice, way too much cheese, pretty good sauce, crust was doughy and had a ton of extra flour overall sal’s pizza one is not as good as sal’s pizza two
vinny.napolitano4/21/20, 4:46 p.m.
The Sicilian will change your life. The regular plain slice is very good 7.4ish. But the Sicilian is 8.3 all day everyday.
connor.coppola10/11/19, 5:55 p.m.
Chicken bacon ranch is amazing. Hands down some of the best pizza on earth
denace8/13/19, 9:05 p.m.
Great sauce. Good cheese. No real crisp. Bottom line: If you’re in the area you’re coming back to Sal’s. That’s worth at least point two. Eight point one. That’s a review.
t_petruccio8/9/19, 11:53 p.m.
Order a regular pie with hot cherry peppers, onions & sausage...cooked well, great flavor and good crisp in the crust
frank.reese8/9/19, 4:16 p.m.
Tad flop. Good crunch. Nice and thin. Touch of grease. Good football pizza. Good sauce.
mark.d37/21/19, 11:05 p.m.
Solid pizza. Nice and crispy and very flavorful. Get a Gelato while you are there, you won’t be disappointed.