Sal's Pizzeria & Catering

Classic pizza party pizza, nothing really special about it. At all.

My favorite pizza place to go when I used to live near Sayville. And it’s really good pizza! Just came out of the oven and it’s definitely crispy, especially the crust! The cheese and the sauce definitely has good flavor to it because it’s light. Love it!!! Michael’s rating: 8.7

Tried the grandma Ala vodka slice great taste but a bit greasy so for that it gets an 8.2 that’s a review

best pizza ever

The cheese and tomato sauce is really good and the pizza is very crispy 7.7

The Sauce is amazing, very good, but my cheese fell off immediately, and it’s not bad just missing something

Great flavor and perfect cheese to sauce ratio, which is why it was not a greasy mess. The score could be next level if it was a bit thinner and crispy. But for sure a local go to.

Slight flop. Great tasting slice. Good amount of sauce and cheese. Great slice

Nice thin slice, but bottom could of been more crispy and not so doughy-Anne Little chewy-Steve Needed a crispier bottom, flopped so much it almost ripped all in all not bad slice but could be better-Josh

Best regular slice in town by far and top 5 in Suffolk County

Getting good pizza in the patchogue area is tough...great tasting regular slice. Nice staff, great standard slice slightly above average in the area

I hate to do this the Oriole in there are great... this pizza is awful, taste bad, doesn't hold together well just low quality ingredients... and the sauce taste like chef boyardee... going from umberto's to this is like filet mignon to spam... sorry to be so harsh but it's bad

A little sweet. We dig it. :)

Good slice, good crisp, needs a little bit more sauce IMO.

Good crust, perfectly cheesy.. needs more sauce

Big flop. Very cheese. Kinda alittle messy. Very tasty. Great sauce.

Not bad Sal, not bad.

The pizza had a great crunch but after the initial crisp it has a doughy bite. The sauce didn’t blow me away with flavor but it’s an overall solid slice