Sal's Pizzeria

This is extremely good pizza. Crispy, Little Flop, and Good Crust. But the best part of the pizza are the toppings. When walk in you are immediately met with tons of different varieties of pizzas each with unique toppings ranging from pineapple to spinach to bacon to olives. It’s the only pizza I tried in the cooperstown area but it must be the best you can get in the area.

Not to many options i. Town for pizza so it’s nice to have a place like this….solid pizza and slice options that I would go back for when in town!

DANK THIN SLICE MY BROTHER

Sal’s is a must in Cooperstown. Pro move order a full pie. New owners use the original recipe.

Pizza was doughy big and not crispy. Garlic knots were a 7.5 and good. Would recommend when in Cooperstown! ⚾️

Not bad, probably best pizza in Cooperstown!

Awesome, authentic NY pizza spot at the HOF

I got one cheese slice and one pepperoni slice, Good crunch , no flop but crust was over cooked and too light on sauce

Sauce is okay. Warmed up a but much

Dry and heavy on the flour, but overall good

Solid crust- comes out very hot- very solid NY style pizza

E’s first review!

Great crunch. Fresh. Fast. Really good.

Best in Cooperstown

Great Crunchy Thin Crust. Buffalo Wing Sauce is Perfect blend of spice and tang.

Very good. Crispy crust, no flop at all. Good sauce and cheese. A Hall of Fame slice.

Solid slice. Crust is good but something is missing from the sauce.