Salvatore's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Great coal fire style! Worth the drive

Love the fresh ingredients and organic feel. Doughy and lacks an extra punch of seasoning. Sauce isn't enough to stand on its own when it's this forefront.

Incredible, some of the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. It reminded me of the fresh margherita slices you get at Joe’s in Manhattan. Huge crispy bubbles in the crust, and the sauce was tangy and fresh, with little seasoning but just a pure, flavorful robust tomato taste. The prices are pretty high though, but you can tell you’re getting really high quality ingredients.

Solid solid pizza

I’ve come realize Dave and I see the world thru different taste buds. Place was great. Fresh Mozzarella, tangy tomato, and don’t forget the basil.

Great crust, better sauce…Salvatore’s. Well worth a visit, pricing is the only thing that kept this away from high 8’s.

8.0 right on the dot. Very good sauce, good undercarriage, came all the way from Eastern LI to try it, very good!

Top 3 coal fired 🍕 in all of NY. Thin crust, good char and always fresh ingredients ingredients. They only serve pies, no slices and 💵 only.

Ain’t she a beauty!!! Great spot for coal oven pizza if you have never had it before. Super thin, very tasty, a lil floppy, but hits the spot. A good mix of oregeno with some other spices that give it a very distinct taste. You can easily down 4 slices in a matter of minutes. More sauce then cheese, but again the sauce has a very particular taste. We got the garlic bread pizza and highly recommend you pass unless you want to smell like garlic for a week. Enjoy!!!

Overrated by all, ay oh… very soft crust. I’m sure score would have been higher if they cooked it longer. Looks better then it tasted. I was a little disappointed… Yeah, I’m back. Ohhhh!

Great sauce and cheese, the crust was good but below the sauce and cheese wasn’t crispy enough, it was a little soft instead of being crispy.

Some of the best pizza on Long Island…. Thin crust, evenly spread cheese and sauce

Great pie.. we had it to go which doesn’t help. We’re between 7.8 - 8.4 in the crew I ate with. Amazing pizza prob best in the area

Totally unacceptable flop, pizza is consistently cold. Sauce is very good though.

I’ve been going here for 5 years the pizza is excellent 10. Garlic bread is really good 10

Went to Salvatores back in August. The pizza tasted great,nice and thin. But the crust could have been more crispy. Went back-in September ordered it well done . One bite everyone knows the rules 8.2 so much better well done. Give it another shot Pres.