Salvatore's Tomato Pies - Madison

Dave’s 7.4 score here is fair. I don’t think it’s his favorite style so might be a tad low compared to what the rest of us see it as. But overall good place. Cool vibe, cool part of town, good service. Fresh ingredients and we thought the crust was solid.

$13 for well done one topping 10 inch. Pretty good crisp and very saucy. If you like the sauce will probably be in 8s or higher for you. For me it was a solid well done pizza. Right price and appropriately scored by most people.

Great pie! Authentic, fresh ingredients made perfectly.

Hands down one of the best pizzas in the state. Great crust, not too thin - not too doughy, with good flavor. Fresh Wisconsin cheeses. All sorts of interesting specialty pies but regular pies also stand their own. It’s a must for pizza lovers across Wisconsin.

Pizza was great. The crust was some of the best I’ve had. But what was better was the staff. After a fellow customer made us feel uncomfortable, they apologized and made us feel much better. Overall an sweet experience.

Needed more sauce otherwise damn near perfection

Tastes like cruise ship buffet pizza. Toppings might be a must here

amazing

Believe the hype folks

Solid pizza. Great crust, good sauce to cheese ratio. Nice sauce but I feel it could have used a bit more seasoning or something to bring this pizza to the next level. Overall a great pie!

Really good pizza. Great cheese and sweet sauce. Very nice crust.

Good. Left half great stuff flop. Great crust. Right half..floppy.

Really good pizza. Awesome staff! Could use a little more cheese and time in the oven. We had takeout so it did sit for a bit. Otherwise real good pizza.

Incredible za, sharp photo and even sharper Taste

Was too high and hungry reevaluated my score from 8.2 to 7.8

Quality Wisconsin Pizza