Salvatore's Tomato Pies

Not a bad pizza by any stretch, but don’t be deceived by its looks. The crust was very good, and the undercarriage was decent. Somehow the pizza just got progressively floppy to the point where it was mushy, so that knocks it down a decent but. Good toppings, good cheese, sauce had a little tang to it (not sweet by any means). Overall good spot in the Madison area.

The first thing you notice when you pick up this za is one thing. Flop. It was crazy, probably the craziest amount of flop I’ve ever had on a pizza pie in my life. Aside from that, there are a couple good things. The cheese was probably some of the best I’ve had on a pizza. Although the sauce was pretty tangy, it was still good. The crust was alright, but was chewy all over. I would score this pizza higher, but I cannot get past the flop. 7.7 that’s the review

This pizza was good at first. The more I ate it, the more I hated it. It sits like a brick in your stomach after you’re done with it. It’s super floppy if you get the 16 inch. It looks like it would be crispy, but I thought it was very doughy. It’s worth a try, though I wouldn’t go back.

This is the best pizza in the Madison area hands down. The crust is crunchy the toppings are quality the item distribution is spot on it’s very delicious. Pizza is like sex, it’s always starts at a 5. But when you get a 9+ all other pizza is sub par.

Great crust and love the sauce. Always get the tomato pie so I tried the fat tony as well and did not disappoint. Best place I have had pizza around this area so far.

Amazon

Pictured is a 16" Tomato Pie with Pepperoni. The sauce is prize winning. The sauce has great flavor that complements the cheese and basil toppings. Its downfall is its bread like crust, but the crust is still better than most in the area. At $18.75 Still a great date or movie night pizza. Do not waste it on children unless they have a job that can pay for one. Until then, They will be fine eating Glass Nickel.

Decent

Solid pie, better than most. Sauce was a little sweet, but that didn't detract from the crust, which was flavorful and very well cooked.

Great sauce. Lots of flop but the crust is still delicious 🍕

Light crust, good amount of flop. Taste is okay.

Great! That classic Tomato Pie is on point. Thin body with a super light airy crust with crisp! Quality pie!

Good crust, lot a flop, solid pizza with great sauce!

Decent sauce, ok crust, kind of floppy.

Very good Neapolitan pizza! Got the meat baller and the carbonara. Both awesome specialties. Crust is fairly crispy and a bit charred. Sauce is solid

Best in town