Sammy's Pizza In Neenah

“Do I want your pizza in a box?” Uh I dont know is this a pizza in America? Took it in the bag just to say I’ve done that now. I stayed optimistic in spite of rolling up to a shop I thought was closed because it literally only had one light on and not a soul in it at 8 PM on a Saturday night. I think I stumbled on a shop in its final stages of life because the pizza I ate was not any better than the ambiance. Can’t believe they’ve survived with such good options in the area.

I got a house and sausage slice, both were very good. The house had quite a bit of flop, but the sausage was perfect. The place has an older feel and the guys making the pizza were very friendly. Waitress gave us the thicker crust to try for free but wouldn’t get again, kind of doughy.

best pizza in the valley. #onebite