Pizza worth traveling for. Pro tip: order it well done.
fullytorqt12/11/22, 4:32 p.m.
I’m giving it the same score as the other San Biagio’s. Virtually the same pie. Must order well done and still a bit too much flop. Love the flavor though. Haven’t found better NY style around.
mason.lane3/3/21, 10:16 p.m.
Good solid pizza. I was expecting it to be spectacular based on what I've heard. All in all you aren't going to find much better pizza in California.
bruinfantony6/13/20, 1:12 a.m.
I have been to both locations and not much difference if any between their pies. Since I have been picking up Dave’s just one bite reviews on my FB feed I have been dying for a good NY style pie and San Biagio’s is the closest place around. Just one bite. It’s a good pie, the thing that kills the score is the sauce. It’s not the best it kind of fights against the good crust, and cheese. Not as oily as some have complained on yelp. They were getting pretty busy for an early Friday night and yet my pie was ready in 10 minutes as I waited outside. Staff was friendly but I just can’t get past the sauce. Can’t put my finger on it, it’s not like there is to much oregano or garlic there is something that is just off. Not as good of a Pizza as Joey’s in La Verne but they are two different pies.
jay.sharp14/11/20, 4:14 p.m.
Only real deal NY pizza around. Great owners, get your pie cooked well done!
joshua.praytor2/18/20, 3:56 a.m.
Very good pizza. Would be in the 8’s if it was cooked a little longer.
noah.matteson1/24/20, 2:12 a.m.
All right Frankie, you the rules. One bite, everybody knows the rules. The pizza had some flop. Not a soggy flop. Just a two inch flop. It was the venom flop of the mcu. Great taste, crispy crust. And blazing hot. My tongue won’t have any taste buds for a week. A little greasy, but I’m sure that’s from my sausage and pepperoni addition. Great service even though they didn’t know who I was. Like, I’m the Vice Pres. you should know me. Overall, a 7.9! Could’ve used a little less flop, but the pizza tasted amazing. AND, they had wild cherry Pepsi on tap. Let it be known Frankie, I will be back.
kmerk8/2/19, 3:36 a.m.
I get Pepperoni cuz I don’t fuck with cheese. But decent slice okay flavor but I got bored of it fast.
christian.valencia2/14/19, 12:34 a.m.
One bite everybody knows the rules. Descent slice of pie, needs some more zest with their sauce. Football pizza no doubt.