Santoro's Pizzeria

Best NY style pizza in a town where there surprisingly isn’t any other good NY style. I think the community is fair at 7.9 but I’ve always liked their bread consistency, which is why I place it *just* inside of the 8’s.

Oily but good slice

found something in your purse that made me really uncomfortable. Maybe we should alk about that first.

Damn good! Crisp, great sauce.

Goooooood!

Solid slice specialty slice was very good

Thin and delicious. It’s arguably one of the best pizzas I’ve had. Disclaimer - I have not been to CT/NY/NJ.

Very crunchy. Amazing pizza. Tried the cheese, grandma slice, Philly cheesesteak, and others. All amazing. Not greasy at all!

All the staff was super friendly, it’s in a great location and the building is super cute! However this was one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. It was like eating cardboard, with cheese. There was no sauce, no flavor, and too crunchy. I’ve had better frozen pizza.

Greasy, floppy, no flavor. Dave screwed up on this review. It’s seriously worse than chuck-e-cheese.

Good Pizza with zero flop!! Staff was welcoming too!!

Every bite was perfect

Really great pie for Florida, if I was doing a strictly FL rating would get a 8.5

Really solid pizza. My wife and I preferred Gramma’s style, which is made with plum tomatoes and has a fantastic texture. We both gave it a 9.1. The Sicilian was not my style, yet it was still very good (mid to high 7s). The cheese slice we all agreed was in the low to mid 8s, and the Margherita was high 8s. So, with the variety they have, and the fact that it’s not expensive, you’ll find something you love. The guy running it, as well as the girls working there, were all just super nice. Loved talking to them and hearing some of their story. They were out of stickers, yet the owner still managed to rummage through his bag (and even looked in his car) to get me one. Great vibe, great pizza.

Great crisp on the crust. The cheese tasted great and had some good seasoning. Not the best under carriage. The place was packed on a Friday night.

Very good. Nice crisp. Has some good seasoning on it.

Excellent crust and perfect amount of cheese. Great spot.

Cheese slice was nice and thin, consistent flavor, solid crust. The margarita slice had better flavor and reaches an 8.1 for me. Square slice is by far the best of the 3. Overall the average of the 3 is a 7.9 rating. Doesn’t come close to Violet Stone in terms of the best pizza in Tampa.

it was a greasy mess this time. Service is going way down hill. Last Two times about a 30 minute wait for two slices and watched at least 10 people get their orders filled first that ordered after me. Bye-bye.

I didn’t finish it. We're rating it 6.6 and wondering if this was the pizza place that Dave rated because it's nowhere near a 7.9. Maybe wait a couple of months before trying it because they're busy and pushing the pizza out the door.

Actually very good pizza for Florida.