bryce.sobieski10/14/21, 1:53 a.m.
Pizza was light and not greasy, I didn’t get dough belly after eating it, which is nice because other pizza joints in Tampa like the shit box that is New York New York pizza do give such. Good pizza do recommend.
kevinmckeon910/14/21, 1:41 a.m.
Closest thing to NY pizza down here, coming from a New Yorker.
nicholas.wolf9/4/21, 6:20 p.m.
new yorker in florida. this slice was much better than i expected fro ma florida slice, just lacked a bit of crisp throughout the slice. cheese was great tho.
jillian.mittica8/6/21, 10:49 p.m.
Okay we're here on Cass St in Tampa. One bite, everybody knows the rules. Great undercarriage and crisp. Delicious sauce and cheese. Best in Tampa Bay!
richard.rivard7/10/21, 6:16 p.m.
Pizza is probably best in Tampa. Light body. The crust is crisp. Sauce is great. You can taste the basil and it has a little sweetness to it which I love. Literally drive 35 minutes to and from my home to get a little New Jersey style pizza. Staff is great also.
floridascott6/23/21, 1:42 a.m.
Pizza review just blocks away from downtown Tampa. Nice family run restaurant and they are proud to be a New Jersey themed restaurant, even though they say New York Style on some of their advertisements. Saw many pictures of my old time favorite place Seaside Height NJ on the wall. 1. Slice was a slight bit smaller than avereage but the price was also a slight bit cheaper. 2. Dough had no flop and was made to perfectuon. 3. They use the Grande brand cheese, which I learned about years ago in Upstate NY, and is among my favorites. 4. I did 2 other reviews, out of my over 50+ in the past, and found that they had an oregano taste and aroma that slightly over powered the overall pizza. The other 2 places got high ratings from the public and this one I will give good too. My suggestion to this place is to cook the oregeno into the sauce only, and not add more, just my opinion!!
fratrick4/18/21, 11:38 p.m.
Buffalo chicken pie and it’s terrible, why are there onions and where’s the chicken
israel.sanders3/29/21, 2:13 a.m.
Really, really, really good pizza. Highly recommend them. Just as good as the NY joint downtown, cheaper too, and not as crazy. I also ordered some of their meatballs. Those were insanely good.
kmacdonald883/26/21, 8:53 p.m.
Disclaimer: Was late to pick up and had to heat it up. But this may be one of the best in Tampa. It could be even better in the store. Great crisp and the smell brings me back to Jersey. Not greasy at all and no big flop. Will grade again in store next time. Big fan.
mason.perlman3/16/21, 11:33 p.m.
I got the Buffalo chicken and I believe the grandmother slice. This pizza is amazing. Crispy crust, sauce is very good, good amount of cheese and toppings are great. One of the best I’ve found so far in Tampa
barstooltampa3/11/21, 1:43 a.m.
Great Pizza! Bought it by the slice (*will be a little colder), $8.14 - 2 slices and a coke ($ Pretty Good), Had a great crisp, Nice “Undercarriage”, Cheese was the perfect blend! Ambiance needs a little work but they just opened up so there is not much going on in the lobby, BUT I will say you do get that New York “Feel” when you’re in here. Dudes yelling in the back (like in NY), Clean Area, Staff is Super Nice! Love It! Highly Recommend! Support Small Business! (7.9 - If the pizza was a little hotter I would have gave it an 8.1)
tommyyg3/9/21, 10:17 p.m.
New kid on the block here Frankie... very nice slice... thin and crispy. I had a late afternoon slice so I would figure more sauce taste right out of the oven. Definitely coming back Nice work!!
robert.flagg2/8/21, 5:49 p.m.
Absolute piss missile of a pizza, out of the park with the Granny style. One of the only spots in Tampa (if not the only) that gets their pizza right.
sollysailor2/3/21, 7:07 p.m.
Classic good NY slice. Great crisp with exceptional sauce and cheese. The guys do it right for Tampa Bay.