Santoro's Pizzeria

Wow what a disappointment. The place was packed and I was expecting an incredible pizza and it did not live up. Now realize I always get cheese and sausage so I am basing my review on that as always and what was the biggest miss was the sausage, gross. It was more of a sweet pork sausage, not Italian sausage like you find on pizza in Chicago. This was awful. Had I gotten just cheese it might have had a better score but I could not get past that horrible taste. After 2 slices I threw out the rest of an 18 inch pizza.

It doesn’t suck. Margarita is better. Probably a 7.9 but the pepperoni is 7. I’m tipping my score to the Margarita side. Zero flop great sauce. Pepperoni was floppy and just did have that tangy pop like the other. Still a good pie

Great pizza. It has great undercarriage, crunch and again, pairs perfectly with the DC. I think the cheese here is a must get and their lunch special w 2 slices and a fountain drink (obviously dc) is a snag

Great classic NY Pie. Crust is almost perfect, great sauce/cheese ratio. Definitely up there as the best in Tampa. Haven’t had much better in this area. Great pie

Greasy. Must have been an early days 7.9 from Dave.

Stop 2 on our pizza crawl. A real pizza joint. A true New York area type pizza. Sicilian was good but the cheese came off in one bite. 6.8. The round brought you back to your childhood. No flop. 8.3.

One of the best slices I’ve had. They also have one of the best speciality slices selection as well. Certainly the best pie of pizza I have had in Florida so far.

Sauce is good, cheese is a bit lacking. Overall, decent.

Crust was the best part Definitely Resembles a mall pizza… Floppy and little crunch.

14" SPICY HAWAIIAN BBQ Ham, bacon, pineapple, cherry peppers, mozzarella, BBQ drizzle

Decent crunch, cheese was good, sauce decent I would like to have a little bit more kick to it. Also, there wasn’t much of a flop, but there wasn’t a ton of taste with the crust. I’d like to see it have a little bit more proofing.

Cheese slice was mid. The buffalo and chicken vodka slice was fire

very good, great undercarriage and zero flop. great crust and not to cheesy

More of a cheesier pizza than a saucy pizza. Very good!

8.4 on the Margarita

Good slice just was disappointed by the cheese which I review. If you like a spot that does specialized slices this is the spot for you (buffalo chicken/mommas are what I’d recommend)

Some of the best pizza

Awesome pizza!!!!

Solid plain slice. Crispy. Sauce lacks a little flavor. Buffalo slice very good. Definitely can compete in the tri state