Sarefino's Pizzeria & Italian Deli

Send this slice back to New York.

Frozen

Good crisp, tangy cheese, not over sauced. 8.1 that’s a review.

Looks better than it really is. It is super greasy, which takes away from a great undercarriage. Cheese and sauce nothing special. North Market is fantastic but the pizza is sadly lacking.

Decent slice that gets the job done, but nothing to write home about. Good undercarriage and crisp crust, decent sauce, bland and greasy cheese.

Surprised the score is so low, but everyone has different tastes… I thought this was pretty good. Crispy, good dough, sauce and cheese. I’d have it again, especially since Hot Chicken Takeover is charging for napkins now….

Crust was too crispy. Too lightly sauced, would’ve liked a wee bit more. Cheese dispersion was solid however. Overall, I’m left content, but not eager to return.

This is really not that good. So many other better food choices in North Market. The sauce might be the only redeeming quality.

Good pizza. Chewy crust, nice flop and quality sauce

Below average New York Slice. Not terrible tho.

Solid pizza

Decent Crust, very basic pie.

Great New York style slice of pizza, no flop, good sauce, maybe a tad greasy. Great service!

A little bit on the greasy side, basic cheese, and a tad of sauce on it; pretty much your standard food court pizza slice.

Tastes like something United States postal office would transport. Cardboard erect crust. Burnt like toast. Sweet sauce like a jolly rancher. Pizza is pizza good slice when you’re slam chizzled. Decent yeese

Sarefino’s Pizza , my favorite NY style pizza in Columbus. Thin and bottom is crunchy (no flop) with great flavors. A little grease and good cheese.Only thing is edge crust could have been less chewy. Note if you go, their pasta and sauces next door are excellent too. (Pastaria)

Average pizza, it’ll do for a quick lunch but I would never go out of my way for it.

Pretty good. Could use some more cheese especially toward the crust side.