Bit overrated. Sauce was good (as it should be given the name), but Ive definitely had better slices. Low 8’s are more like it for this place.
chris.rivs2/14/21, 11:54 p.m.
8.3 very good but not the 9 we expected from El Prez. Calabria in NJ still the best we’ve had so far.
tour_de_pizza2/13/21, 9:53 p.m.
As far as “slices” go, it’s. 9.2, overall pizzas: 8.9. Excellent crust, cheese texture, & sauce tang.
coolguyian1/31/21, 11:36 p.m.
The ingredients taste like they’re from Italy if that makes sense? Reminiscent of a Napoleon style pizza made like a New York slice. Good stuff
snehal.mehta1/24/21, 5:31 a.m.
Thin and the basil was a nice touch. Overall a good slice but not a 9.1 for me.
harris.eisenberg1/9/21, 2:20 a.m.
Dave gave it a 9.1 so I had high expectations. Overrated. Crust was cooked well but pretty bland. Sauce was great but not enough. Cheese was good and basil gives it nice flavor. Solid slice but not in the nines.
thephillyscumbag1/5/21, 3:37 a.m.
Well I am a buffoon for taking that photo which doesn’t do justice to the slice. They have the place named sauce for a reason. Outstanding! The crunch and the cheese were on point. The Pats smoked the Bills that night in 2019, perhaps the last time we see that in a while.
arvind.singh12/30/20, 4:13 a.m.
My son gives it a 112 but I’ll go with an 8.9. Great slice perfect cheese sauce a tiny bit on sweet side for my liking but still a solid slice. I also had their vodka slice which is a 9.6 in my opinion. By far the best vodka slice I have had. We went late on a Sat night, Had this pizza been fresh out of oven the vodka slice may have been my first 10.
5 views•0 likes
columbuspizzaking12/16/20, 11:04 p.m.
I have eaten at mostly all the top pizza places around and a lot in nyc. This is by far the best single slice shop in the us. Hands down not even close. The customer service they provide is also the best you will get from anywhere else . Visitors to nyc should make this the first stop they have . I know we will. Excellent pizza