Preferred the pepperoni, but both were great slices. Especially liked the puffy crust and the subtle heat in the tomato sauce.
matthew.kelly35/5/22, 7:36 p.m.
Crust was fantastic you can tell this guy mills his own flour… really all you can ask for from a slice joint..would give the plain 8.7 and the hotboi grandma a 9.3 ridiculously good slice
justin.turner3/27/22, 5:29 p.m.
Classic New York slice; thin and crispy. Had to wait 25 minutes to get two slices, but it was worth it to have it fresh. Sauce immediately stands out, has a unique kick to it.
mister.slice3/19/22, 7:11 a.m.
Big New York slices! Usually pretty long New York lines too, but it’s worth the wait. Fantastic sauce, quality cheese & delicious dough make this one of the better slices you’ll find in Manhattan. Filling, satisfying, gigantic NYC pizza!
boba3/17/22, 3:32 p.m.
Incredible pizza and delicious sauce. If you ever go here please please try some of the hot honey and/or order the hotboi. I would give the hotboi a 9.4
efotoguy2/17/22, 9:30 p.m.
Nice thin crust. Good char. Yum with a drizzle of hot honey Solid NYC slice. #OneBiteOneBitOnly
scott.nakamura10/6/21, 11:48 p.m.
Best New York slice so far! Staff is really friendly too!! Must try when you’re down there!
danny.miller119/25/21, 3:36 a.m.
SCARR'S IS A TOP 5 PIZZA. you won't regret it. The hot boy is a 8.7
joel.pfeifer9/14/21, 7:00 p.m.
A hot fresh slice with no flop and perfectly crisp! Sauce could be a little sweeter, but still the best in Manhattan.
kevin.price8/21/21, 10:42 p.m.
Well done this time second stop of the night second time and upping my score. Perfect quintessential slice sweet tangy sauce sets the tone with the right amount of sauce and crust that’s screams what am nyc crispy slice is all about!!
todd.richman8/1/21, 5:04 p.m.
Had the cheese and the hot boy. Great crisp on both, good sauce on the cheese. Glad I went and easily one of the best in NYC.
jeff.star7/22/21, 10:01 p.m.
Awesome pizza! Great sauce and crust. Crispy and flavorful. Can’t wait to eat it again.
enrique.ripley7/13/21, 6:04 p.m.
Great great pizza! You really can’t go wrong with a regular or Sicilian
brian.madeleine6/17/21, 12:04 a.m.
Crispy crust, great sauce, cheese thicker than expected and creamier which was a plus. This was better than joes. Definitely would eat again when visiting.