mike.lawrence35/21/21, 10:37 p.m.
The jalapeno honey slice is the one to get here.. it's not as spicy as you might think, and the mix of spicy and sweet with the honey is next level
ryan.rutherford5/19/21, 5:32 p.m.
This may not look like an aesthetically pleasing pie, but thankfully it tastes way better than it appears. The sauce is pretty fantastic, somewhat sweet with a decent kick, definitely unique and very flavorful. Really good crisp all around from the dough & crust. This is actually the epitome of pizza flavored dough: that distinct taste that separates it from bread. The cheese is creamier than I expected and also has really solid flavor and flow. This is a total NYC pie: huge slices, very filling but not overly thick. Overall, it’s a real pizza’s pizza, everything about it is as pizza as pizza gets. Lines are usually pretty long cause it’s a trendy hipster spot, but despite being a little overhyped, it’s still a damn good pie and one of the better spots in Manhattan.
harry.hoffman4/22/21, 1:29 p.m.
Stellar, stellar pizza. Great crisp, flavor, I also got the hot honey on the side which added really good flavor. A must visit.
one_slice1/5/21, 3:29 a.m.
Huge and expensive slice. Taste don’t justify the price and hype but still a decent slice.
mart.smyth12/6/20, 3:57 p.m.
Had Starr’s again yesterday and it was super on point. Posting again to bump up my score
ecao10/4/20, 9:22 p.m.
Cheese slice: crunch wasn’t the best, but the dough may be the best I’ve ever tasted (so far), good sauce & cheese, but neither extraordinary; the cheese was burnt just the right amount, which enhanced the flavor considerably
matthew.anderson148/7/20, 7:29 p.m.
I’ve had mixed experiences here but I’ll give the 8.1 frankie
jerbraska8/2/20, 7:51 p.m.
Pretty standard slice. Flavor wasnt all that unique, but good slice nonetheless
jtm27277/6/20, 12:05 a.m.
Preferred the pepperoni, but both were great slices. Especially liked the puffy crust and the subtle heat in the tomato sauce.
alex.dripchak6/27/20, 8:37 p.m.
The archetype of NY style pizza. Nothing more need be said other than it’s better than Joes.