Scarr's Pizza

very lackluster and overpriced slice. if you’re into basic pizza, this is probably up your alley. i like a simple pie, but this was lacking any sort of character

Prepare for thinner pizza

Low key place that will surprise you. Off the chain! One of the best pies I’ve had! Sauce is sweet, cheese is gooey ooey and crust is chewy and light. Highly recommend.

Good crust, but cheese and sauce a little underwhelming.

8.5 if more crisp

Uhhhh, been meaning to try this slice for a long time, but was not about to wait in line. Thank god I didn’t. It’s not a bad slice, but it’s nothing to write home about and definitely not something to line up for. 7.3

Very doughy, sauce and cheese were underwhelming. Nice presentation and very filling

Beautiful crunch, nice sauce, fresh slice

Listen, it is not worth waiting an hour for a slice from this place. There are far better spots like Patsy's or Luigi's. The Sicilian slice was served burnt, and the 2 regular slices were good but not outstanding. If there's a line when you get there, just keep going.

Crispy. Perfect sauce.

Good but not worth waiting 35 minutes in line for.