This place is famous for a reason. The cheese is on the saltier side which compliments the super sweet sauce. Solid pizza.
jars56/3/20, 10:48 p.m.
Bad picture but worth the 40 minute drive. Sweet sauce and grated cheese makes this pizza stand out from others. Never greasy. Never soggy.
spachyspach3/8/20, 9:11 p.m.
Keep coming back for this cheese steak pie, best I have ever had. The plain has a delicious sweet sauce, but man that cheese steak!!!
ayyyygimmeameatball9/27/19, 11:04 p.m.
WHAMMY! Has that sweet Caroline sauce with the razor Ramon KrUST! Little doughy but what the hell
spookyscaryskeleton8/3/19, 10:55 p.m.
Great Sicilian pie, sausage was amazing. Sweeter sauce complimented the cheese and crust well.
billy_the_kid6/27/19, 10:55 p.m.
Legendary sweet sauce. Extremely thin crust with a great taste. Best pizza in NJ.
m.mo35/1/19, 6:11 p.m.
First time having this and I must say very good pizza. Sauce is sweet nice taste and good cheese. Tray pie well done, well worth the trip!
mike.oxfloppin3/18/19, 10:49 p.m.
Im all for a little sweet in the sauce but this tastes like a vat of domino sugar was dumped in the pot.
25 views•4 likes
mattkleski3/16/19, 8:12 p.m.
Couldn’t give it the 7. Looked like a 9 tastes like a 6.5 Overall though I’d recommend...biggest problem was the sauce didn’t match the slice. 6.9 that’s a review happy patty’s day.
samantha.scaplen11/23/18, 5:29 p.m.
Overall this pizza was a good pie. The sauce was nice, the pizza had some flop and it was nice and crisp. However, although the sauce we good, they’re was way too much of it. The cheese fell off and there was a lot of grease. It fell apart after a bite. This isn’t a pizza you would take home. More of a wine and dine kind of thing.
carlos.velazquez11/23/18, 4:58 p.m.
Over an 8? Alright Frankie, let’s take it back a little.. the sauce was good. Definitely fresh. They failed to mention that the meatball pie had NO CHEESE. Dine in spot, can’t just pick up a slice and go. Said 3 words to the waitress the whole time. Besides the sauce.. didn’t really do it for me. Not a football pie either. 4.3, deal with it
mike.karafa10/20/18, 1:21 a.m.
Alright Frankie... Scirotino’s in South Amboy. Great thin crust, amazing sauce, gotta get a large pie cuz it’ll be gone in the blink of an eye. “This is the kind of pizza you gotta tie your hair back and get on your knees for” - Isarel That really says it all