Best pizza I’ve ever had, better than any NY slice. Coal fired, and extremely flavorful. Go for the lobster pizza!
johnm7/22/21, 11:54 p.m.
Quintessential bar/football pizza. Crispy undercarriage, lotsa cheese, and overall good experience. That’s a review.
dschmettk6/23/21, 10:48 p.m.
While good and a fix for a seafood craving this pizza is not something I would travel over 20 minutes for. If in the area it’s definitely worth a try for the first time but beyond that I’m not sure I would order it again. It is very rich and greasy with the garlic butter and fontina. The crust was very good around the edges but understandably floppy with the amount of butter and grease that compiled in the middle. Good pizza; but while some may think it fucks I would say this pizza cuddles with the hopes of something more before you fall asleep.
gopanthers6/20/21, 8:42 p.m.
The view and mojitos were a 9.9… Pizza was okay, thin, good crust. Too much cheese and not enough sauce for me to go any higher.
sam.orchard5/10/21, 11:07 p.m.
This place was great! We ended up going three times when we were in Key West. Had three different pizzas - favorite was the Four Cheese and Prosciutto. Great service - check this place out!
joseph.moffa3/10/21, 1:14 a.m.
Great location. The cool thing is that they have a good truck in the sand. They have wood fired oven in the food truck. Very good pizza, the coconut shrimp were very good also.
8 views•1 like
alyssa.crone1/1/21, 10:52 p.m.
Some flop, crispy edge of the crust. They have a signature cheese blend and you can taste the difference, it's really good and tangy. Less sauce but not lopsided. Enjoyed it.
jonathan.parrott12/10/20, 6:32 p.m.
Beach ambiance +. Regular cheese 7.8. Lobster pizza is their go to 8.3.
bobbradley10/6/20, 9:46 p.m.
Wood-fired, awesome crust texture and taste, bottom floppy and soggy... too many cheeses too much oil. Decent slice, taste is there, crust is there otherwise a bit of a mess.
jjr8/20/20, 1:17 a.m.
Crust is awesome but middle of the pie could use some more crunch. White sauce, so no tang, basically a lot of garlic flavor but it works great. If you want a pizza further south, you’ll need to hop a boat to Cuba. It’s Key West, so the lobster is a great addition when you’re ocean-side. Good pizza.
21 views•0 likes
matt.gay16/20/20, 2:52 p.m.
Great pizza overall. Doesn’t warrant travel from the next state over, but it’ll do the job. Their wood fired oven is pretty sweet, but could use a little extra crisp. 7.9 that’s the review
jake.biederman21/4/20, 8:47 p.m.
Fancy pizza. Good amount of sauce and cheese. A little New York flop but nothing a little flex of the hand won’t fix. Definitely one of top pizza places in the Keys.
daniel.spurlin11/14/19, 5:53 p.m.
Good char. Small flop. If you are in Key West you should try this pizza.
david.bogese10/30/19, 9:11 p.m.
Fire roasted light crust. Very nice tomato base with excellent cheese. Excellent place to get great pizza complement with good beer over looking the water.
scott.calabrese6/23/19, 6:35 p.m.
Dough a little chewy, a bit light on the sauce. For Key West, I’m not mad at it. Okay, but not great. Folks scoring it an 8.7+ must have started drinking at the opposite end of Duval St. before getting here. Let’s face it, f you’re drunk most things taste great.
kyle.stabenow6/11/19, 5:26 p.m.
Picture perfect, authentic wood fired pizza. One bite you know the rules.
jameson.billings6/10/19, 4:18 a.m.
Found the app, found the pizza, died and went to heaven! We decided to try out One Bite on our trip to Key West and the Seaside Cafe was our first stop. There’s literally no need to go anywhere else. How is this even real?!?!? Perfect crust, perfect bite, perfect combo of flavors. We’ve been eating pizza all over the world and the wife and I agree, this pizza is the best tasting thing that we’ve ever put in our mouths. Not traditional pizza by any stretch, but the Duval Street Corn is the thing of wet dreams.