Seaside Cafe at the Mansion

Best lobster pizza i have ever had!! It has some flop but the taste of lobster and butter on it makes up for it!! the crust is nice and crunchy! It’s definitely a must try if you’re a pizza lover and in key west! A little expensive but it’s AMAZING

Not enough crisp salty and greasy sauce had a great taste cheese under delivered

As someone from CT, this place shows glimpses of New Haven style pizza. Great atmosphere and great pizza!

Visiting the Keys was the last leg of our honeymoon. So of course, I had to finish off the week with a pizza review. Decided on this place based off of Dave’s review. We settled on the “world famous lobster pizza”. The pizza itself was actually very delicious, and the hot sauces were top tier as well. 7.4 that’s a review.

Hard to score a pizza that’s not just cheese. Got the world famous lobster pizza wasn’t too bad definitely unique. But the 3 different hot sauces it comes with are it!

Defiantly try the Lobster pizza when in Key West. The views are not bad either.

Great pizza great taste light crunchy real distinctive taste

The honey on the pizza was throwing me off a little bit. I was later informed that there were pizzas without honey

Delicious pizza! Love the consistency and the flavors of the ingredients! Crust has a nice crunch to it, not greasy pizza.

Great location, staff, and excellent lobster pizza!

Had the four cheese with prosciutto and arugula. Very nice and the setting right off the ocean is amazing!

7.2. Great service at the bar! Great taste, sauce is on point. Dough is a little chewy. Would eat this every day!

Lobster pizza and lobster biscuits are a great hangover helper

Had the regular and the gluten free. Probably the best gluten free pizza ever. The regular cheese was good. Very crispy and light. Noah gave it a 7.6

Full disclosure; I was intoxicated while consuming this pizza, hence why I snapped a pic of it being half eaten. Very good slice with limited flop, a good undercarriage and a good tang. 7.4 is a fair score.

High expectations, and it delivered!

Lobster fell off crust was pretty good

Quintessential bar/football pizza. Crispy undercarriage, lotsa cheese, and overall good experience. That’s a review.