Secret Pizza

Secret Pizza makes a great slice. A little pricey, but nice flop and crust. White pizza is also excellent.

Dave must have been high the day he reviewed Secret Pizza ! It’s a grea slice in a great environment. The reason everyone knows about Secret Pizza is because it’s delicious! Stop it and get a slice if you can find it :)

6.2

Greasy, sloppy, drunk pizza. It’s not worth the stop even for the “secret” gimmick.

Legit and without ANY b.s. the Secret here is it's overpriced and not worth a visit unless you're in Cosmo already and ONLY if the line isn't 40 people long. 20 MUCH better food options within 50 ft. Staff slow and some rude too.

Grease city. But great crust

Definitely over hyped but no way it’s a 3.4.

Solid 7. Greasy but the cheese and crust were on point. Sauce is lacking flavor or it would be svored higher.

Love.

Super crispy. Had a reheated slice which wasn’t ideal, but was crispy and decent. El Prez was wrong on this one.

Drunk

This pizza does not make the cut for being $5.25 a slice, especially with a line as long as a short par 4. I like that it is thin and crispy, but it’s also a bit too chewy. The cheese was nice and had good flavor. The sauce was non-existent, a major contributing factor to why this pie was so dry.

Very middle. Tasted like it had been sitting out for too long before reheating.