Had this pizza on Easter Weekend 2026 and I’m still thinking about it. I’m familiar with famous New Haven pizza (big 3) and Boston Pizza like Regina and Santarpio’s… Sergio’s is awesome New Haven style pizza - crust, sauce, cheese, including how it is cooked and sliced. Got a large cheese pizza and a medium tomato pie (sauce and parm- no mozz) and both were awesome. Several family members who have been enjoying NH pizza for up to 70 years agreed it was great. People in this area don’t know how good they have it - so the avg score on this app to me is a tough, spoiled New Haven score because there is so much good pizza around that it doesn’t stand out as much as if it was anywhere else in Country and beyond. I can’t wait to go back to Sergio’s whenever I’m back in the area!!!
