The dough/crust tastes great, crisp, zero flop. Just the right amount of cheese. Not overly greasy. One of the better pies in this area.
the-master-reviewer2/15/23, 2:51 a.m.
Decent undercarriage and sauce, medium flop. Sauce was solid
lebrian.james1/28/23, 9:31 p.m.
This pizza is delicious. I took a 45 minute detour home just to try this place. It had a good crisp in every bite. The cheese was very tasty and there was minimal grease. I didn’t notice the sauce at first, but after a couple of bites I realized it was delicious as well! The further you got up the slice the better the pizza started to taste. I’m very glad I took the time to try this place. If I lived in the area I would be here at least once a week.
beach.pizziola3/13/22, 2:16 a.m.
Good neighborhood pizzeria Crust is light & chewy Sauce is thick w/ slight spicy taste Cheese blend has good tug Nice char for a gasser Cool staff
t.brownstone2/26/22, 1:51 a.m.
Very Solid Pie! Crust and Cornicione are well cooked, crispy, and there is little to no flop. Sauce is the highlight, sweet and garlicky with just the right spice. Cheese is good, but average. Overall this is pizza done well!
rugbylifer1/12/22, 10:02 p.m.
Very good pizza. Crust is what you want out of your pizza. Owner takes care of you and makes sure it’s done right. It’s his legacy and obviously takes pride in his pies. Def would eat there again!
matthew.kump4/3/21, 4:48 p.m.
Solid football pizza, probably top 2 in our (Carlisle, Newville, Shippensburg). area. No real flop, decent crisp, crust tasted good but was a little thick, cheese was average. Definitely enjoyed it, My kids and my wife liked it too. Super friendly staff - Mike was on point and quick with making the pizza.
blade.robinson3/19/21, 4:36 p.m.
Everything about this pizza is perfect. Outstanding sauce, great crunch cheese is delicious best pizza in the state of Pa!
smals11/9/21, 5:42 p.m.
Good crispy undercarriage. Not much flop. Minimal grease. Very good very crispy crust. Good garlicky, flavorful sauce, with a slight kick. Good cheese. Overall great pizza.
michael.schmalz3/14/20, 5:34 p.m.
Delicious sauce and very good crust. One of the few pizzas where I eat the actual crust, it is crunchy with a soft inside.
adam.dawes3/8/20, 3:23 a.m.
Great pizza—sweet sauce and salty cheese make this my favorite spot in the Carlisle area. Solid pizza and great people! Ask for my boy Mike. He’ll set you up with a magnificent pie.
nichole.mills10/27/19, 1:32 a.m.
You don't need any other topping besides cheese on this fantastic pizza!
wheez.weller8/1/19, 9:54 p.m.
Very solid pie. Crust was top notch, no flop. My boy gave it a 7.8, I gave the pie a 7.9, but the owner was extremely nice and passionate about his pizza so I bumped it to a 8.1
gabriel.ganser7/28/19, 3:56 p.m.
Good solid slice. Good crisp. Flavorful. Not greasy. Nice atmosphere and friendly people.
mrpizzaofpa5/23/19, 4:06 p.m.
Ok.. so Steve-n-Dots is one of the top rated places in central pa, not to mention when I asked my friends and family on Facebook for the best pizza place, they were the highest commented venu. Upon walking in, you’re greeted with what feels like an old bar and dining room. Kitchen off the back, people super friendly. Now, for the pizza. It looks like every other football pizza. But boy, was I surprised on first taste! The crust, it’s everything you want and more in a pizza. Amazing crunch, crisp, and flavor. Cheese is salty, fresh, yet light. No oil. Only reason I’m not in the 9’s is that the sauce left me lacking. If I had a tad more sauce, this would be my #1 recommendation for pizza in Central PA.
teddyfade0512/13/18, 4:41 p.m.
Pretty good flavor. Asked for it well done and came out pretty perfect. Good pie.