Sexton's Pizza

This was my first time eating this type of pizza. The pizza itself tastes decent but the crust is thick and way too crunchy for my liking. The staff were very kind but the store has no phone number to call. 6.5 is my score.

Not messy. Good crunch. Great crust. Just not anything special. Not enough sauce

Good crust

amazing za

One of the best slices in Columbus… they need to figure out how to function their TVs though

Some of the best if not the best pizza I’ve had in Columbus. If all I knew was Central Ohio pizza this would be in the 9’s.

Definitely phenomenal pizza, me personally I’m a cheese lover and I would have liked to have just a little more cheese. Overall very satisfied and the crust was crispy yet soft in the middle.

Lots of crunch, light and crispy. Toppings could be more consistent…best pep and cheese in town.

Quality Cheese and sauce with excellent flavor. Crust has that extra done crisp and doesn’t get soggy. A Columbus/Hilliard must try.

Great pizza

Good but sauce is off

A quality pizza, I'd drive 3 hours for this. Amazing crust, good sauce, the cheese had a great flavor. I think it could use a bit more flavor overall, but it was a fantastic slice.

This pizza smelled great (simple New York cheese pie). The crisp of the crust was amazing and the flavor very good.

Highest score I’ve recorded has been an 8.7. This is by far the best pie I’ve had the pleasure of sinking my teeth in outside NYC. I can only hope Columbus area appreciates what they have here. Great GREAT pizza. Yet they have a bunch of other items on the menu. Full bar. For me I’m more of a lighter cheese guy but I am in the minority I know. I am really amazed.

Too much char for me on this particular pizza but this could be very good.

Excellent pie. Crust has the crispiness of a wood fired pizza but still has a good flop. Flavorful cheese and pepperonis. Delivers on the hype. (apologies to followers, had to repost at this location bc was not coming up in search earlier. Dave this app is ass)