Sexton’s Pizza

Great place, pizza was New York style a little thicker than thin , good undercarriage, a bit floppy and moist , but got better as it cooled , all in all a really good pie . They only have 16” and some square pie about as large . Will return but not in my top five or ten favorites

Great Pizza! Well balanced with the cheese being tangy, sauce has a great taste with sweet and tomatoey flavor, and the crust is airy yet very doughy. Not much flop, which is good. But I just wish it had more of a char to the undercarriage and crust to add more flavor. They were speedy and had great quality control over all pizzas. I will say it’s one of the best pizzas in Columbus area. Overall it’s a solid 8.0.

Tasted good, but really floppy.

This is a great pizza with a bubbly crispy crust and just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Loved this whole experience.

One of the best pizzas you can get in the Columbus area. Typically, New York-style pizzas are not that popular here; however, having Sexton’s as an option, you don’t need many other places. Amazing!

Incredible pizza. Good crisp, light and fluffy. Incredible atmosphere in there as well and very nice workers. If ur in Columbus you have to try it

Cheese and extra sauce™️. Kinda sweet. Great crust. Kinda floppy. Worth a visit if near by.

Too much cheese and not enough sauce but solid crust and cooked well. From what I’ve heard it’s the best around Columbus

Great crunch. Almost zero flop. Great under carriage. Very good sauce but would like it to be a little bit thicker. You can tell it’s homemade sauce

East Coast Vibe. Quality slice. Good people. Crisp, bubbly, light pizza. Maybe better cheese makes it closer to 9. Great place to grab a pie and a pint.

Great undercarriage. Really good taste, perfect amount of cheese and sauce. That’s the review.

Nice undercarriage. Little on the thick side overall great taste

know you're in a frat, but what made you think it'd be alright to wear a Miller Lite® sweat band to church with my family?

I didn’t enjoy the flavor and it was a bit dry and overcooked for my liking, but I know some people love it this way. It is all about preference so you may like it better.

Crispy crust. Good flavor, a little chewy.

Great Crisp, tasted fresh, even after driving home it tasted like it just came out of the oven!