Best in town!
josiahmarton4/19/20, 2:14 a.m.
All out of pepperoni cause of Corona so went with cheese. Had good flavor. Would have been higher with pepperoni but it is what it is. The Pinwheel was really good. I’d give that an 7.9.
xseangarciax3/14/20, 9:59 p.m.
Good thin pizza with a lot of flop. Might have to try it by the slice and see if it’s a little more crisp that way which would probably put it in the 8’s but the sauce was good ,the cheese was good , the pepperonis were great and the ratio was great
musicn0twar2/12/20, 4:12 a.m.
The pepperoni was the better of the two. Good crunch to the crust and the roni’s were delicious. Not much flop here!
carl.neumann1/20/20, 2:31 a.m.
Had super high hopes, it's ok. I ordered the double baked, and although they confirmed it when I picked up, but it's very doughy. Place was busy and had a good vibe.
mut12/28/19, 3:54 a.m.
Excellent game day pie. Flavorful sauce and crispy Pepperonis. Opt for well done. No complaints here. Bonus points for friendliest pizzeria staff in OC.
king_josh312/13/19, 5:11 a.m.
A little greasy... a little floppy, but too much flavor to ignore!! One of the best pizzas in OC. Highly recommend. 7.9, that’s a review.
peezaapeeza11/21/19, 8:38 p.m.
Good crisp. A little greasy but solid ingredients. Football pizza with a nice bite compared to the options available in OC.
alexander.king111/20/19, 1:59 a.m.
Sgt Pepperoni has a pretty solid recipe. Thickness is halfway between thin crust and standard crust. The cheese is flavorful, there is a little flop, toppings tasted fresh and very slightly crunchy on the underside. Not much at all to complain about. It had the highest overall review score in the area and I believe it. While it may not dethrone the NYC legends (Prince St Pizza, John's of Bleecker, etc), Sgt Pepperoni holds its own against most of the NYC slice market...and I eat tons of pie in NYC. Score: 8.5 My Order: 14" half cheese, half pepperoni / green pepper, well done.
j_shelden2511/3/19, 1:49 a.m.
Has some weird flavors that aren’t perfect. Dough isn’t special either, but it’s a decent representation of a NY slice which is hard to find here!!
bradley.brown39/4/19, 9:43 p.m.
Solid football pizza, I kinda regret getting the full pie. The cheese slips of of the pizza because I think there’s to much sauce. Crust and cheese are good. Probably could have gotten higher if the bottom crispness was more consistent.The ricotta meatball is excellent.
grant.mason8/11/19, 4:08 a.m.
Pretty good spot for pies. Cheese: 7.0 (Not going to give the 7.1) Grandma Slice: 7.8 (As pictured) Leaning towards scoring the traditional cheese, but overall it’s a 7.3 spot.
arianna.valverde4/1/19, 7:52 p.m.
Decided to try this place because of their partnership with Miss Orange Coast. The pizza is great, nice and cheesy with a good flip. But the real star of the menu are the pinwheels. They are so gooood! The pull apart is amazing with the sauce and cheese oozing out of every crevice. These are a must try, since it was hard to only eat one. Overall, the vibe is great. They have every game showing and the service is quick.
katie.mendel2/17/19, 10:22 p.m.
Cheese literally melted in my mouth. Thin slice with a crispy crust. Flop was outstanding. That’s a review
mood.dawg1/3/19, 3:04 a.m.
Good slice. Fun atmosphere for counter slice place and great service. Grandma slice was better— 7.4.
gee12/29/18, 1:33 a.m.
Really solid pizza by the slice joint. Good Happy Hour too. Get the garlic knots and a pinwheel too
kevin.malin12/12/18, 5:53 a.m.
One of the better OC slices. Consistent all around. Pleasantly crispy crust. Favorable cheese to sauce ratio. Slightly underwhelming flavor but not discouraging. Will revisit!
richfahgone12/12/18, 5:47 a.m.
Very impressed. Sauce not tangy very fresh tomato essence. Dough tasty, great crisp on the crust. Nice and thin. Limited flop, not greasy at all. Good cheese. Solid 6.9 and to be fair, didn’t eat fresh, prob 40 after pickup with a quick oven reheat. Tbh may have been a 7.2 right out the oven. Once again, impressed for Cali pizza. Well done Sgt Pepperoni’s.
sam.silvers11/16/18, 9:43 p.m.
A little heavy on the grease but solid crisp to the crust. Stong flop. Football pizza