If you’re for a quality New York pizza: Sgt. Pepperoni is your kind of pizza. General tip: always call in and order a pizza; don’t call/walk-in and ask for a slice — it isn’t as fresh and you can taste the difference.
My favorite is the MEAT: it has all the types of meats you can imagine — and only meats. It’s a great pizza got meat-lovers such as myself.
My 2nd favorite is the BBQ chicken. I usually ask for mine with extra BBQ sauce bc I feel like the chicken tends to get dry. However, the past 2 times I’ve had the BBQ chicken it’s been phenomenal.
I tried 2 new slices this most recent visit: the Buffalo Chicken and the Meatball Ricotta.
The Buffalo Chicken was a lot better than I expected. The ranch sauce layer wasn’t overpowering, and they put just the right amount of hot sauce drizzle on top. (I did get a slice, so I could taste that it wasn’t as fresh since the chicken was slightly dry).
Lastly, the Meatball Ricotta is great for the lasagna lovers out there. When you take a bite, the meatball and ricotta instantly remind you of a traditional lasagna. As a huge lasagna fan myself, this pizza was surprisingly good. I loved the clumps of ricotta they dispersed throughout the slice — I just wish there was a little more meatballs... (Again, I ordered a pre-made slice of this pizza, but, I could tell that a fresh one of these bad boys would be delicious).
Overall, Sgt. Pepperoni’s is our favorite local pizza place; and, we can’t wait to try more different slices next time we visit.
