Sgt. Pepperoni's Pizza Store

Loads of cheese, not thick regular NY crust, overall no undercarriage — 5.9 and I was starving

Pretty nice crust texture-wise, but lacking good pizza crust flavor. Tomato sauce and cheese are slightly above average because they get a decent amount of char. Pretty-good bar-type pizza but not really exceeding the habitual in any way. Cool barn and outdoor area make it a cool spot too.

A lot of flavor and traditional New York look.

Second west coast place since moved out here from the east. Salty and greasy, cheese to sauce ratio is way off, how people are saying “best in OC” just paints such a bad picture for the region LMAO.

Not bad but not amazing.

Slightly above average pizza not the best but not the worst. Could have went lower but had a slice of the meatball ricotta which was really good so that boosted the score to the community average.

Longer oven time. Probably would have made it a 7.5

Whole lotta flop. Lots of sauce. Very underwhelming crust.

All flop no breaks. Underwhelming with a generic taste. Nothing special about it.

Great crisp, thin crust, meatball is delicious. One of the best pizzas I’ve had.

First bite you think this is pretty good. After that so much grease it hurts your stomach. If this pizza gets room temp or a little cold it’s absolutely terrible. Will not be back!

Good hungover pizza. Little greasy. Good crust, would have been even better a little bit crispier

Meh. This is the ricotta meatball. Not awful, but tastes like a frozen pizza. Meh once again.

All out of pepperoni cause of Corona so went with cheese. Had good flavor. Would have been higher with pepperoni but it is what it is. The Pinwheel was really good. I’d give that an 7.9.

Good thin pizza with a lot of flop. Might have to try it by the slice and see if it’s a little more crisp that way which would probably put it in the 8’s but the sauce was good ,the cheese was good , the pepperonis were great and the ratio was great

Best in town!

Had super high hopes, it's ok. I ordered the double baked, and although they confirmed it when I picked up, but it's very doughy. Place was busy and had a good vibe.

Excellent game day pie. Flavorful sauce and crispy Pepperonis. Opt for well done. No complaints here. Bonus points for friendliest pizzeria staff in OC.

A little greasy... a little floppy, but too much flavor to ignore!! One of the best pizzas in OC. Highly recommend. 7.9, that’s a review.

Good pizza! Best I’ve had in the Irvine/Santa Ana area!

Good crisp. A little greasy but solid ingredients. Football pizza with a nice bite compared to the options available in OC.