Shelley's Pizza

Massive flop, little bit of crisp on the crust, very cheesy which personally isn’t my style, but I like a lot they cut their large pizzas in 12 slices by default. Not my favorite slice ever but I could eat this all day and not be upset 🤙

Delicious NEPA pizza with sweet sauce ! Amazing ! 🍕

Super thin, no flop. Fine pizza.

Fantastic

Light extra sweet sauce with pepperoni. Best in the valley.

Super thin and crispy, spiral sauce design, very little flop. Mozzarella cheese with very little grease!

Solid slice. Got the regular sauce w pepperoni. Good crisp and balance of cheese/sauce/dough.

Rookie score but I actually really enjoyed this pizza. Only slightly bland part was the crust but the way they cook it kind of makes up for it. Good slice.

Alright Frankie, this pie is half their reg sauce/half sweet sauce which might throw off the review. One bite, everybody knows the rules. It's got flop Frankie, chewy thin crust with strange oregano flavored sauce for the regular. Sweet is to sweet, not feelin it Frankie. This is a tough one.

Good taste. Thin, crispy crust.

A clean thin slice with very little flop and very little grease. You like to see that. Also, It has a very nice and even sauce to cheese ratio, but needs a little bit more of each. With that, more of a crunch would be desired as well, but is overall, very solid like Jeff Fisher’s career.