Shelly Pie Pizza

Average pie. Pie is too doughy and the crust has too much air. Sauce has an average flavor without any zing. +.02 for the great atmosphere.

6.8 for the taste. Super floppy, super greasy, and honestly too much pepperoni on it.

Nice size slices. Overly cheesy. Cheese is good. Sauce is good. Crust is doughy. But crust tastes very dough like. That’s the down fall here.

Pleasantly surprised with this pizza. I usually don’t like super heavy pizzas, but the sauce and cheese combo was extremely tasty. Other than the super doughy crust and the nature of fork and knife pizza I can’t really complain.

A lake of grease, no structure. Major flop, too much crust. Not great.

Enjoyed the sauce and cheese but the crust is to much or would have been higher

Wayyyyyyyyyy too much under cooked crust

DISGUSTING! A greasy mess with tons of layer of pepperoni. I counted 16 slices stacked up! Worst pizza I’ve had in Pittsburgh hands down

Cheese very generous, sauce and bottom crust good. Back crust very thick so it feels a bit underdone. Extremely greasy. Good pie overall.

Great taste, nothing but flop (knife and fork required) too much cheese.

Hard to eat without utensils. Spicy Pep, excellent sausage, big slice! Solid score

Very average Pie. Way too cheesy, chewed each bite for 25 min and the grease was absurd. Pizza was swimming in it.

Loads of crust, cheese, flop and flavor.

Too much cheese. Drunk people pizza.

Hands down best pizza I've had in the Pittsburgh area. This pie is HUGE and delicious. A large would feed 4 average dudes. The toppings are piled high, definitely get what you pay for. It should come with a disclaimer: "Dont make any plans after eating this pizza." The only con - the slices are so big and heavy with toppings that you're not picking this one up. It's a knife and forker for sure.

Toppings!