I had high hopes for this pizza. This was sticking mess of a pizza, the cheese was all to one side. It was under done. The basil was disrespectfully cooked on the pizza. Asked for it to be well done, got the hardest Hamilton flop ever. On top of that it was a $50 order. Pure bullshit
turner9110/4/20, 12:55 a.m.
By far the best pizza I have had in Hamilton. Great crisp, thinner style pizza. One bite everyone knows the rules!
camby10/3/20, 8:47 p.m.
New York style pizza, nice thin dough, super flavour and great texture.
ryan.gal12/23/20, 9:06 p.m.
Solid solid pizza. No flop, crust has a great crunch. Cheese and sauce good quality and bursts with flavour. If I lived in the area it would be a go to spot. Highly recommend
ateyourweight1/2/20, 2:39 a.m.
Great pizza joint. Best New York slice in the city. Thin crust with a good crisp to it.
mike.christie28/22/19, 6:23 p.m.
Best NY style in Hamilton. Great thinner crust, not overly cheesed. Expensive but worth it.
sean.graham4/25/19, 5:45 p.m.
Aright Frankie, we're here at the corner of Cannon and Kensington. Shorty's Pizza. We have a saying here in The Hammer - If the neighbourhood is shit, the pizza is legit. If the pizza flops, you're runnin from the cops. #onebiteeverybodyknowstherules It's good pizza Frankie. Huge east end flop, thin crust, good crisp. Sauce has a little tang but not sweet, very tasty. Little curled up pepperonis are so god damn cute. The crust is controversial...sesame seed! I don't like the sesame. We're not on Sesame Street this is Cannon, home of the Tiger Cats, we eat 'em raw. Good atmosphere, kind of hipster but not annoying. It's understated and clean. An enjoyable place to have a slice or a pie. Great value at $4.75 per slice. The slices are huge. Probably the best pizza in the city. I put them slightly ahead of Knead. I wish I could have tried a grandma slice but they ran out. Shorty's, a must have slice in The Hammer. That's a review.
crust.punk2/20/19, 8:59 p.m.
One bite, everyone knows... Shared a NYC Cheese with friends, it went over well, good representation of a NYC cheese, little flop, very cheesy, ingredients were pretty quality, sauce is a bit too sweet but all in all I definitely wouldn’t be angry ordering this again,7.7. Bonus review time... I recommend visiting the shop and ordering a Sicilian square slice, their take on a Nonna slice, it was legit, proper pepperoni and great spice that makes you forgive the sweet sauce, 7.9.
226 views•2 likes
pizzakevin2/11/19, 10:46 p.m.
This pizza is trying really hard to be good but it’s just lacking flavour - I did like how light it was. Potential is there.
ryan.lancaster9/13/18, 11:33 p.m.
Seasame crust is a nice touch. Little New York flop. A little more time in oven and this place easily hits the high 8s.