Sidewall Pizza

Rating based on bottom half which is a margarita pizza. Really awesome ingredients, seems all are high end. Sauce cheese and crust taste great. This would be in the 8s if the crust was crispier.

Tasty pizza! The crust is usually on point but today it was overcooked. We ordered it simple with pepperoni,mozzarella and goat cheese.

7.5, atleast. I’m a Greenville native and have had Sidewall many times, but this time, the were truly on to something. Each bite had a solid crisp, low flop, and a great undercarriage. Sauce was bright, mozz was just right, and look at all that Basil. Any higher than 7.5 feels like a stretch, but any lower with this specific pie would be a crime. Good stuff Sidewall.

peachy keen / summer vegetable

Cheesy but solid za. I’ll be back.

Good ass pizza, some craaazy flop tho. Recommend getting pizza and a beer here if you’re in the neighborhood

Cheese/sauce ratio is good, dough flavor on point. Very good slice-would have been in the 7s but was very floppy

Good pizza, little greasy, lot of flop. Sauce is a little sweet.

Fantastic crust, above average mozzarella, and sub par sauce

Not bad flop, nice crisp, good crust, and no grease, but sauce lacked tang. Pretty solid margherita pizza

Lots of fancy options on the menu but cant go wrong with the classic cheese. Good crisp to it with minimal flop. Had a healthy char around the crust and not too much grease. Wouldn’t mind a bit more tang out of the sauce, but definitely a really good slice. Service was fantastic and the vibe is very chill. I cut up a piece for my one year old and he loved it as well. Best pizza i’ve had in Greenville.

To spiffy to be pizza. It wasn’t bad or good. The appearance was great but didn’t hold up in taste. All flop and soggy in the center. The crust had no crisp even in the charred areas. Again, not bad, just not my style. Loved the setup though, and the service was great.

Hot Hawaiian. Good crust, sauce and plenty of toppings

Solid pizza, crust is medium between soft and crispy dry, toppings vary, bacon bliss is delicious. Can’t go wrong with sidewall, one of the best in Greenville.

Took this late last night. (I know it says Sidewalk) Quality Pizza. Little flop and grease is to be expected when using proper pepperoni. Respectable slice.

By barstool standards. Great pie, we set the curling at 8.