It says on the box “Best pizza on the SW lakeshore” but this is easily one of the best in the State of MI. Nothing compares to the garlic greek (add jalapeño). Crust: Thin, crispy, crunchy and flavorful with cheese to the edge every time. Just a touch of sweetness. No flop but that’s what you get with the square cut. - 9.2 Sauce: Sweet and tangy but still savory with herbs and spices. It’s not the star But compliments everything else. 8.7 Cheese: not sure what blend hey use but it’s got a unique flavor to it and not too greasy. 9.3 Toppings: High quality meats, fresh veggies and herbs. 8.9 One Bite Takeaway: Consistent every time, this take out-only joint always delivers (thank you). Tastes just as good or better as leftovers. The Whole here is greater than the sum of the parts. Because of its location (in a tourist town on the beach) this pizza is more expensive than most. But around 20 bucks for a 18” pizza this good is worth it. 9.1 that’s a review.
meliodas10/17/20, 5:17 p.m.
Girlfriend was saying 9 while I was saying 8.1. All around very good pizza.
gabriel.kodjaian hamawi9/19/20, 4:52 p.m.
I would get the calzone, made really well pizza not so well but decent calzone would get a 8.5 freshly made get the calzone you won’t be sorry
matt.capparelli6/13/20, 12:44 a.m.
Carrousel pizza minus the shrooms. Great tasting Za! This crust is hard to beat. Goes great after a company golf outing while blacked out! Paired with a Two Hearted tonight.
robert.pockrandt3/7/20, 2:06 p.m.
Great service , pizza was pretty good the jalapeño pizza only in the 6s as it needed to be a thinner crust the main pizza with all the toppings was very good and worth the $$
pizzapat2110/5/19, 10:02 p.m.
West Michigan’s finest Frankie! Off the palatial shores of Lake Michigan, you’ll find the absolute BEST cheese/sauce ratio coupled with a crisp on the crust that can be heard in Chicago! Flavor Town 101. That’s a review Frankie!
28 views•5 likes
trump20249/29/19, 5:42 p.m.
Went with the Garlic Greek with jalapeño based on a previous review. It was great. My highest rating so far. Enjoy!
gade.raftery8/2/19, 2:17 a.m.
Solid pizza with lots of cheese. Good pepperoni flavor and crust.
carter.mulvihill7/14/19, 4:51 p.m.
“It’s like pizza on garlic bread” As a Chicago guy in Michigan, Silver Beach was a pleasant reminder of Aurelio’s. High-end ingredients all exceptional. Cheese was on point.
scott.bartley107/7/19, 12:52 a.m.
Sauce is kinda sweet which I enjoy. Toppings and crust were pretty good as well. Love the location with it being really close to the beach