Slammies on High

Ratio is off. Very Cheesy, little sauce, good chewy crust

Good. Flakey, but light crust. Good amount of sauce. Job well done.

Solid slice NY style. Nothing amazing but solid. Bit of flop.

Not great, not bad… just pizza

Overpriced and just not that good. Hate to say it, especially because Catfish Biff’s closed but it simply cannot replace Biff’s as a late night slice on South campus of OSU. Even a drunken Jimmy Johns is preferable to this

Very solid pie. Good sauce, crust was cooked nicely. Just an all around solid pizza.

A top tier NY Style slice within the metro columbus area. This slice rivals East Coast pizzeria which is found a few miles north on the same street. The cheese and sauce is what really carries this pizza for me. The sauce is tangy but not acidic just the perfect amount of tang. The cheese is a good quality mozzarella with a soft texture. I believe the crust is the weak point which is why the score didn't carry over into the 8s. The crust is a bit doughy and thick and you will need a couch break after eatting to slices. Now let's get to the best part of this unique experience for Ohio. The owner is the nicest coolest pizza guy I've met in all of Ohio. He is the motor behind this establishment and makes the experience very memorable.

Really great service. Italian pizza that’s definitely the go-to place on campus.

Decent cheese and sauce, not cooked well so some flop, but overall ok slice.

Pretty cheesy and soft dough with decent crust

Eh

Pizza by the slice. 2 pieces for 7 bucks. Good solid pizza. Got a NY vibe

Best slice I’ve had in Columbus. Owner is super nice even threw in a roll for free. Closest thing in Ohio to an authentic NY pizza by the slice

Not a bad slice... could see myself eating here normally but the sauce was not to my liking... A 7.1 is a fair score but has room for improvement!

Great crust, good sauce and no flop. Pepperonis and cheese were very average.

Solid Piece!! Great crust from start to finish. Definitely one of my favorite pizza places around Columbus. It is a must try slice!